Martin reviewed Archangel protocol by Lyda Morehouse
None
3 stars
This was a ridiculous crossing of genres. At times it was a noir detective novel, but set in a near-ish future USA where a brain-implant-accessible internet/VR exists, but also where religion is so ingrained into our culture and society that it's illegal to not have a registered organized religion with the government. As if all that wasn't enough, (I'll admit if that was the extent of the weirdness, I'd definitely be intrigued), angels – as in messengers from god – are real.
I think the angel thing is what tipped it from "an intriguing sci-fi premise" into "annoying urban fantasy" for me. There are a lot of threads un-pulled here, and plot holes as big as the biggest ones in the bible. I thought the main character was so full of hypocrisy that it was incredibly hard for me to empathize with her.
The fact that this is a local …
This was a ridiculous crossing of genres. At times it was a noir detective novel, but set in a near-ish future USA where a brain-implant-accessible internet/VR exists, but also where religion is so ingrained into our culture and society that it's illegal to not have a registered organized religion with the government. As if all that wasn't enough, (I'll admit if that was the extent of the weirdness, I'd definitely be intrigued), angels – as in messengers from god – are real.
I think the angel thing is what tipped it from "an intriguing sci-fi premise" into "annoying urban fantasy" for me. There are a lot of threads un-pulled here, and plot holes as big as the biggest ones in the bible. I thought the main character was so full of hypocrisy that it was incredibly hard for me to empathize with her.
The fact that this is a local author, and recommended by a friend of mine, kept me reading to the end. I even bought used copies of the two sequels to this book, but I can't see myself reading them any time soon. Maybe I'll keep them on my shelf to maybe read them... someday.
Added 2023-07-19: I think I was a bit harsh in my review. There is a lot to like about this book! The GLBT representation in particular is well done, especially considering its publication date from over 20 years ago. I was musing a bit, and if you removed the "angels are real" business, I actually do think this would be a fun book. I still probably wouldn't like the protagonist much, but that's not unusual for a lot of PI/detective/noir stuff for me.