interlibraryprone reviewed The Terraformers by Annalee Newitz
It's space fantasy trying to use science words to look like sci-fi
1 star
I like climate utopias, so wanted to like this. The pacing and time jumps sucked. The attempts at "Cree futurism" felt inauthentic and inappropriate from a settler that didn't seem connected to Cree culture. I had a hard time buying the idea of moose as mounts, and a lot of the wordbuilding just didn't feel thought through.
I read it as part of QueeReads Montreal. A friend asked me what I thought of the intersex representation, and it confused me. The book doesn't have intersex representation. The Archaeans in the book are genetically engineered to have mixed sex characteristics. This isn't intersex representation - if it's normal for a given (sub)species, it's just how that (sub)species is. Intersex means having naturally occurring sex traits that are different from what is expected for your species.
So much of the attempts at looking like hard sci-fi were cringe. How do …
I like climate utopias, so wanted to like this. The pacing and time jumps sucked. The attempts at "Cree futurism" felt inauthentic and inappropriate from a settler that didn't seem connected to Cree culture. I had a hard time buying the idea of moose as mounts, and a lot of the wordbuilding just didn't feel thought through.
I read it as part of QueeReads Montreal. A friend asked me what I thought of the intersex representation, and it confused me. The book doesn't have intersex representation. The Archaeans in the book are genetically engineered to have mixed sex characteristics. This isn't intersex representation - if it's normal for a given (sub)species, it's just how that (sub)species is. Intersex means having naturally occurring sex traits that are different from what is expected for your species.
So much of the attempts at looking like hard sci-fi were cringe. How do they have glass plating that lets you see inside a volcano? How are metal robot submarines navigating inside volcano magma? This stuff would have gone over so much better if the writing embraced being space fantasy rather than trying to pass it off as hard sci-fi.