ogd5XOt reviewed Legacy of Ashes by Tim Weiner
Commendable research, but too little context
3 stars
The book reads like a grocery list of failures, which is fine, but there's just too little context. Very little space is spent explaining why things didn't work - the reader is mostly left to conclude that the plan was stupid and the people attempting to execute it were also stupid.
The author also goes out of his way to share his disdain, either through direct editorializing or sharing an anecdote to demonstrate the outrageous behavior of the people involved. Simply describing the failure would have been sufficient - the remainder just made it seem like the author had an axe to grind.