Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA

English language

Published May 20, 2008

ISBN:
978-0-307-38900-8
Copied ISBN!

View on Inventaire

(15 reviews)

Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA is a 2007 book by Tim Weiner. Legacy of Ashes is a detailed history of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) from its creation after World War II, through the Cold War years and the War on Terror. The book is based on more than 50,000 documents, primarily from the archives of the CIA, and hundreds of interviews with CIA veterans, including ten Directors of Central Intelligence. Legacy of Ashes won the 2007 National Book Award for Nonfiction.In a press release coinciding with the book's release, the CIA claimed: "With a strong range of sources, Tim Weiner had an opportunity to write a balanced history of a complex, important subject. But he did not. His bias overwhelms his scholarship. One cannot learn the true story of the CIA from Legacy of Ashes." However, The New York Times reviewed it positively, calling it "engrossing" …

14 editions

Commendable research, but too little context

The book reads like a grocery list of failures, which is fine, but there's just too little context. Very little space is spent explaining why things didn't work - the reader is mostly left to conclude that the plan was stupid and the people attempting to execute it were also stupid.

The author also goes out of his way to share his disdain, either through direct editorializing or sharing an anecdote to demonstrate the outrageous behavior of the people involved. Simply describing the failure would have been sufficient - the remainder just made it seem like the author had an axe to grind.

Review of 'Legacy of Ashes' on 'Goodreads'

i wish i read the reviews before i bought this, once weiner got to post-war italy and incompetent agents handing over sackloads of money to dodgy informants and then took us away from italy without mentioning anything about CIA stay-behinds i started to realise how liberal the author's outlook was. i just started to skim from that point onwards, the hypothesis seems to be that the CIA was a state within a state doing things completely alien and counter to the interests of american democracy, that its allying with israel was some sort of error or accident, etc. etc. avoid at all costs

avatar for dstokes

rated it

avatar for 5easypieces

rated it

avatar for ianbishop

rated it

avatar for dan_oglesby

rated it

avatar for mistertim

rated it

avatar for cjhubbs

rated it

avatar for kevbot9000

rated it

avatar for rinze

rated it

avatar for sgclark

rated it

avatar for AndyB

rated it

avatar for nosmo

rated it

Lists