Sean Bala reviewed A Time to Keep Silence by Patrick Leigh Fermor
Review of 'A Time to Keep Silence' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
"A Time to Keep Silence" by Patrick Leigh Fermor is a short, beautifully written meditation on the nature of silence in the modern world and the continuing presence, despite numerous pressures, of Christian monasticism. The book consists of three essays centered around three different monasteries - two living examples in France (one Benedictine and another Trappist) and one abandoned example in Cappadocia, Turkey. Though the essays are distinct, there are a number of general themes you see throughout all three. A first theme is absolute strangeness of monasticism - a strangeness that has always existed and continues to the present. This is demonstrated most clearly in the third essay, which takes Fermor to an elaborate but abandoned monastic community in Turkey. The contrast between the desert and the beauty of the buildings and paintings is striking. But this strangeness is not necessarily a negative quality and its that contrast between …
"A Time to Keep Silence" by Patrick Leigh Fermor is a short, beautifully written meditation on the nature of silence in the modern world and the continuing presence, despite numerous pressures, of Christian monasticism. The book consists of three essays centered around three different monasteries - two living examples in France (one Benedictine and another Trappist) and one abandoned example in Cappadocia, Turkey. Though the essays are distinct, there are a number of general themes you see throughout all three. A first theme is absolute strangeness of monasticism - a strangeness that has always existed and continues to the present. This is demonstrated most clearly in the third essay, which takes Fermor to an elaborate but abandoned monastic community in Turkey. The contrast between the desert and the beauty of the buildings and paintings is striking. But this strangeness is not necessarily a negative quality and its that contrast between monastery and world that helps us also see the strangeness of the world itself. You can also see this idea in the surprise the author feels in the contrast between the extreme actions of the monastics (especially at La Trappe) and their normality. A second theme is the resiliency of monasticism - time and time again monasteries have been attacked in the West and yet they always find ways of taking root. A third theme is the process of alienation and dislocation that comes from entering into the monastic world. Again, I should note that for the author, this dislocation is not necessarily a bad thing. This process is especially well drawn in the first essay centered around the Abbey of St. Wandrille de Fontanelle. Fourth is the power of silence to transform. A fourth theme is the presence and power of silence. This is a short read but one that raises good questions. It also is a good travel book in that it give the reader an excellent sense of place.