I just loved this episode. I do not get what various people online are complaining about, and I really don't want to get what they're complaining about. I loved the various nicknames Spock collected (Spocko, Uncle Sock). I loved the whole alternate future happy life interlude, and that we really didn't know what was going on while it was happening (real possible future? Nexus illusion? hallucination?). I do hope Pike gets to keep those memories. I loved all the interactions between Spock and Kirk, leading into their later friendship, and all Kirk's facial expressions. I thought Kirk's explanation of how little he likes Vulcan mind melds was a nice joke in terms of foreshadowing--how many times in TOS must he have experienced them? (I don't remember, I'm guessing.) I'm glad they kind of wrapped things up with Batel in a way that was plausible. After all that Gorn stuff, it seems reasonable that she couldn't emotionally just go back to being a lawyer, no matter how big the promotion. And now we know why he'll be able to go live his life out with Veena eventually. But instead of Pike just losing Batel, they got that whole extended future memory thing first. I loved during that sequence when he unexpectedly came back healthy when he was expecting to meet his fate--both their discussions about whether there is fate, and how badly shaken he was by not having this awful thing happen that he's been counting down toward for 9 years. I liked their repeated references after that to being on borrowed time they didn't expect to have. Overall, I thought it was an excellent episode. #StarTrek #StarTrekSNW