Back
Benjanun Sriduangkaew: Scale-bright (2014) 4 stars

"Julienne's aunts are the archer who shot down the suns and the woman who lives …

shallow but promising

3 stars

this book is short and sweet. it tells the story of julienne, the niece of two immortals, finding cautious love to a serpent within a short adventure to heaven. and while the premise is intriguing, the book falters due to its length: many scenes could have, should have, been given a bit more time to breathe. introductions of characters feel rushed and by the end we are left with what is a story arc about finding courage in love, but just barely. especially disappointing since the wlw dynamic (pretty much everyone in this book is lesbian) is lovely and could've benefitted from some more depth.

the appendices, which consist of three short story that serve as a kind of prequel to the main story, provide context and a lot of verbose language, perhaps due to its rooting in chinese folklore. especially the second one, woman of the sun, woman of …

@IngaLovinde@embracing.space to be honest, i thought the descriptions of hong kong were rather anonymous. the setting was mostly window dressing. both heaven and the demonic inbetween world had way more identity. contrast this to the way chloe gong described shanghai in these violent delights -- it really couldn't have been anywhere else. but i think at least some of that is due to the length of the work. when you have three entirely different settings in less than a hundred pages, one of them is bound to fall by the way side and with how vibrant the supernatural ones are it seems reasonable that the "ordinary" one has the least identity