LETS BE CLEAR. By no stretch is Josh anything other than a massive red flag. But like…I was over here kicking my feet like “WHAT he’s not stalking her for over a year and threatening to kill anyone who looks at her?” (Cough cough Alex from the first book) The parts of the story that didn’t center around the romance I also thought were really well done and somewhat interesting. So I think just because Josh wasn’t pulling an Alex Volkov and because the B plot kinda slayed here I am giving it 3 stars. The bar is in hell for this book series, truly. (I’m probably gonna read the 4th one🥲)