I actually think this is my favorite book of the three in the Between Earth and Sky series. I really enjoyed getting to know the characters over the course of the long story. As time went on, I became better and better at visualizing their appearances and their mannerisms. I think Roanhorse really hit her stride with this book, though. For example, the way she recapitulates the theme of the title, "Mirrored Heavens," throughout the book with different characters going through trials that are mirror images of the trials that another character endures, is masterful. It's colorful, it's touching, it's unpredictable, there's a distinct thread of sincere romance that pervades it, and the setting is beautiful. 10/10 will likely read again.
User Profile
Interests: climate, science, sci-fi, fantasy, LGBTQIA+, history, anarchism, anti-racism, labor politics
This link opens in a pop-up window
Sally Strange's books
User Activity
RSS feed Back
Sally Strange reviewed Mirrored Heavens by Rebecca Roanhorse (Between Earth and Sky, #3)
Sally Strange started reading The Future of Another Timeline by Annalee Newitz
Sally Strange finished reading Mirrored Heavens by Rebecca Roanhorse (Between Earth and Sky, #3)
Sally Strange wants to read Empire of Normality by Robert Chapman
Empire of Normality by Robert Chapman
'Groundbreaking ... [provides] a deep history of the invention of the 'normal' mind as one of the most oppressive tools …
Wild Woila reviewed The First Woman by Jennifer Nansubuga Makumbi
Fascinating dive into Ugandan culture
4 stars
A teenage girl in 1970s Uganda comes to terms with patriarchy, family & sisterhood. A bit slow without much emotional connection, but the detailed dive into Ugandan culture & history is fascinating.
Sally Strange commented on The Russian Revolution by Sean McMeekin
Finally, getting into some of the fun juicy details, like when Lenin & co. held a bunch of bank employees hostage to force the banks to let them access Russian state funds and gold reserves.
My impression of this book so far is that it's very good for understanding WHAT happened during the Russian revolution. If you want to understand WHY it happened, this isn't the book that will do that. The book was published shortly after previously censored records from the beginning of the Revolution were released after the fall of the Soviet Union, and it's self-consciously a reaction against the Leninist/Stalinist narratives.
Unfortunately my library loan is about to run out, and someone else wants to read it, so I may have to wait another 3 weeks after this to finish the book.
IndustrialRobot rated Translation State: 5 stars
Translation State by Ann Leckie
The mystery of a missing translator sets three lives on a collision course that will have a ripple effect across …
Tsundoku wants to read A Taste of Gold and Iron by Alexandra Rowland
Sally Strange reviewed The Ministry of Time by Kaliane Bradley
A love story at heart that uses time travel to illuminate a critique of empire
4 stars
This reminded me somewhat of "The Echo Wife" by Sarah Gailey in that it's science fiction turned inwards rather than outwards, focused on the individual rather than the grand sweep of history. Considering that time travel is a central part of the story, that's an interesting choice, but honestly I think it's a bit inspired, because it's a reflection of the main character's myopia regarding her place in her society and in history. A couple elements weren't inspired: there's a lack of explanations about certain characters and events and there's a twist that's probably obvious to those who pay attention to the signs of such things. Still, thought-provoking overall, and sad and sweet in equal measure.
Sally Strange wants to read Hum by Helen Phillips
Hum by Helen Phillips
From the National Book Award–longlisted author of The Need comes an extraordinary novel about a wife and mother who—after losing …
sol2070@velhaestante.com.br reviewed Hum by Helen Phillips
Tenderness in a suffocating setting
3 stars
(em português: sol2070.in/2024/12/livro-hum-helen-phillips/ )
“Hum” (2024, 272 pages), by Helen Phillips, is a dystopian fiction that is both suffocating and sensitive, about the difficulties of a woman and her family in a techno-surveillance society in ecological collapse.
Despite the futuristic setting, it could just as well be set today, with our current dependence on screens, corporate domination, ubiquitous digital ads, non-existent privacy, disastrous politics and the horror of environmental collapse. The difference is the absurd intensification of these factors, which includes the presence of advertising androids, called “Hum”.
But anyone expecting traditional science fiction may be disappointed, this is more like a backdrop for the drama — of marked internalization — of the protagonist May. Not that this is a flaw, I especially liked the psychological side, without seeing anything too special in the techno-dystopian part.
After losing her job to an AI, May undergoes facial microsurgery, in search of …
(em português: sol2070.in/2024/12/livro-hum-helen-phillips/ )
“Hum” (2024, 272 pages), by Helen Phillips, is a dystopian fiction that is both suffocating and sensitive, about the difficulties of a woman and her family in a techno-surveillance society in ecological collapse.
Despite the futuristic setting, it could just as well be set today, with our current dependence on screens, corporate domination, ubiquitous digital ads, non-existent privacy, disastrous politics and the horror of environmental collapse. The difference is the absurd intensification of these factors, which includes the presence of advertising androids, called “Hum”.
But anyone expecting traditional science fiction may be disappointed, this is more like a backdrop for the drama — of marked internalization — of the protagonist May. Not that this is a flaw, I especially liked the psychological side, without seeing anything too special in the techno-dystopian part.
After losing her job to an AI, May undergoes facial microsurgery, in search of money, for an experiment on methods of obscuring surveillance cameras. Because of her longing for the lost natural world she experienced in childhood, she spends what she can't to take the two children and her husband for a few days in a kind of ecological dome. Unforeseen events, including a well-known internet phenomenon, exacerbate the protagonist's crisis.
It's not an easy read. There is a Kafkaesque tone, of a powerless person massacred by a vast automated system. This is compensated for by the tender moments of warm subtlety, and the character's feelings, without being cheesy. It's also worth it for the impressive ending.
I had read the author's previous acclaimed book, “The Need” (2020). A psychological horror similar to “Hum” in the internalization of a threatening crisis. Another point in common is that the genre of the story is just a backdrop for a powerful inner journey.
enne📚 reviewed Labyrinth by Lois McMaster Bujold (Vorkosigan Saga)
Labyrinth
3 stars
This novella is a quick heist-adjacent novel; the setup is that what should be a quick extraction of a scientist from Jackson's Whole (the black market anything goes planet) turns into a raid on Baron Ryoval's complex. This stretch of books in the series (from Cetaganda through Brothers in Arms, in my opinion) give the breadth of worldbuilding by exposing the reader to a new place that they've heard of before, but haven't seen directly. This story is mostly worldbuilding and action, and especially juxtaposed against The Borders of Infinity that comes up next, I think it feels like a much weaker book.
One thing I like about both this novella and the following one is that they're both complete stories on their own, but then build a lot of context for the two novels that follow. They're also not directly shoehorned into those novels, like The Weatherman was into …
This novella is a quick heist-adjacent novel; the setup is that what should be a quick extraction of a scientist from Jackson's Whole (the black market anything goes planet) turns into a raid on Baron Ryoval's complex. This stretch of books in the series (from Cetaganda through Brothers in Arms, in my opinion) give the breadth of worldbuilding by exposing the reader to a new place that they've heard of before, but haven't seen directly. This story is mostly worldbuilding and action, and especially juxtaposed against The Borders of Infinity that comes up next, I think it feels like a much weaker book.
One thing I like about both this novella and the following one is that they're both complete stories on their own, but then build a lot of context for the two novels that follow. They're also not directly shoehorned into those novels, like The Weatherman was into The Vor Game.
(We also get a lot more Bel Thorne here too, even though I think Bel gets short shrift in the whole series.)
Not so long ago, Sally Strange pointed out to me Bujold's fascination with age gaps, and there is definitely some of that here. Taura is the monster at the heart of this titular Labyrinth, but is also a sixteen year old girl who has been modified to be a monstrous super soldier. I think this brief romance creates parallels for Taura to learn from Miles about being herself and not needing to be airquotes normal; however, this psychological road has already been walked by Miles before, and it doesn't feel like this relationship creates any growth for him. (And, honestly in the future, Miles thinks a lot more about Beatrice than we ever see him think about Taura.)
Sally Strange replied to Leia's status
@Tourma As you should