TaxideaDaisy reviewed Ibn Fadlān and the land of darkness by Ahmad ibn Fadlān (Penguin Classics)
Review of 'Ibn Fadlān and the land of darkness' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
As someone new to this subject, I ended up experiencing this book along a couple of parallel tracks.
First of all: if you are new to this subject – Read the Appendices First! I jumped forward and read them when I was almost finished with the narratives, and wish I had done so much earlier.
The book is divided into several parts:
Intro materials: Chronology pages, Introduction (we would even say, read the Appendices before the Introduction), various Notes, several pages of Maps
Part I: The Book of Ahmad Ibn Fadlān 921-922
Part II: The Travels of Abū Hāmid al-Andalusī al-Gharnātī 1130-1155
Part III: Passages from Other Geographers, Historians and Travellers
(there are 43 of these, dating from 830 to 1349)
Appendices (4)
Back Materials: Glossary, Bibliography & Notes
The main narratives from Ibn Fadlān are straightforward enough. The maps help with place names and travel routes, but after a while I stopped trying to keep up. Parallel tracks here and throughout include the foregoing, plus “why don’t they teach us this in school?” and “this would be perfect as part of an undergraduate elective on this subject” because there is so much here that either dovetails into one’s earlier education – or opens up windows into unexpected realms. I also struggled with the personal names; they tend to be long, and unfamiliar to the American ear. It might be helpful to listen to this as an audiobook some time (which would have other drawbacks).
The rest of the book got to be less enjoyable. It’s to be expected that a compilation of material about the same topic (travel in certain parts of the world) would get repetitive. The many notes were helpful for contrasting and comparing how different writers reported on various topics, especially, for example, “Gog and Magog.”
What went unexpounded but was certainly in our mind at least, was the contrast between the descriptions (including other works) of the travellers here – and Western Europeans of the 9th and 10th centuries, especially. “England” before 1066 was nothing like the Arab world of the same time period.
This introduction to III, 2, for example, speaks volumes:
(page 99) " Ibn Khurradādhbih (c. 820 – c. 911) served for many years as director of the barīd, the Abbasid postal and intelligence service. He was a friend [of] the caliph Mu’tamid (reigned 870-892) and wrote on musical theory, literature and geography. His Kitāb al-masālik wa’l-mamālik (Book of Roads and Kingdoms) is the earliest surviving work of descriptive geography in Arabic. Later geographers, including Istakhrī, Ibn Hawqal and Muqaddasī, augmented and perfected this form by incorporating their own observations and those of knowledgeable travellers. We know from citations by later authors that we possess only an abridgement of his great work. "
Which brings us to yet another parallel track, again related to education. As it happens, we focused on Medieval Literature during our college years, decades ago. It was rather a given that Western European art, history & literature were all that mattered, with a nod to Islamic influences on the art and architecture of the lower Iberian penninsula, if we recall correctly. While for the most part these courses were from the English and French departments, the same was true of Art History classes and other interdisciplinary studies designed to cover a time and place which was hardly as homogeneous as our imagination liked to paint it. Fortunately we have been seeing improvements in the popular imagination.
There were also Slavic studies at our university, and likely Asian as well …. but no intermingling amongst us, academically. Looking back on that now, I can unequivocally say that this was to our detriment.
So while Ibn Fadlān is just a smattering, just a taste, of a topic, it seems like a fairly accessible taste of a critical, and probably still critically underrepresented in American/Western education, part of our shared human history.