Back

commented on Context Changes Everything by Alicia Juarrero

Alicia Juarrero: Context Changes Everything (2023, MIT Press, The MIT Press)

#JuarreroBook Ch. 6 Interlude: Game of Life

We’ve had problems seeing what we're meant to be seeing in the book's examples. This week we drifted off to one of our own, Conway's Game of Life. I'd like to continue a bit with that. GoL is fascinating, and helpful in contexts such as ours, see web.ics.purdue.edu/~drkelly/DCDRealPatterns1991.pdf

So can it give us informative examples of constraints? Here 3 examples for discussion

1) general mathematical relationships that express possibilities/impossibilities with respect to patterns in GoL. These seem analogous to the threshold for connectedness in J's button example (we didn't reach a definite conclusion on that..)

2) variants changing topology and/or synchronicity of updating, please see here arxiv.org/pdf/nlin/0405061

these seem possible examples of 'context' and 'constraint' to me. The way I'm seeing these is as external to the fundamental entities (squares) and their interaction rules. None of that has changed. But tweaking the temporal …

@uh @dcm @dcm @SylviaFysica

some thoughts on topological/spatial constraints of 2) and 3):

- they’re difference makers, but not causes (at least not at fundamental level which isn’t causal anyway) & they can *be* difference makers precisely because they don’t interact with the fundamental rules of the game
(those rules are deterministic and there’s no space for anything else to intervene, as it were); contextual constraints can be layered on top of one another and be more or less ‘hard’ 1/2

@uh @dcm @SylviaFysica BUT for example 3 of constraints facilitating formation of glider guns, we get a constraint based modification of that property (runs with glider guns will tend to go on longer than runs without). BUT to explain the “still active” property I need to invoke the glider gun, I can’t just point to the basic rule set. I can point to the constraint itself, but it’s opaque, and no explanation seems possible (?) that doesn’t go via the intermediate, high level object…. e/