allanderek reviewed Homecoming by Kate Morton
A slow homecoming
3 stars
Content warning I'm going to discuss the main plot points, it's just hard to review otherwise.
This book is pretty readable, but it's slow. It's not clear how much of it is meant to be a mystery, but the main "twist" is very well sign-posted from a long way out. The remainder contains big spoilers so if you want out, now is the time.
I also felt the book didn't really wrap up much of its stories. Should we forgive Polly for her failings as a mother, because she had been gaslighted (and generally controlled) by Nora? Meg, it's clear intended to poison Isabel, but not the children, but did she mean to kill Isabel, or, as her son had intended, simply give her a bad episode? Marcus seems to be concerned that young Thea Turner had been taken by dogs days after she was supposed to have. Did he really not suspect that Nora had taken her and passed her off as her own child? What about Percy? Did he not suspect that? If so, wasn't he interested in his own offspring?
It feels like the whole book is full of uninteresting back story, and then glosses over the actual concluding stories that would have been interesting. In particular Jess's story is not very interesting despite us spending a lot of time at the start of the book on her story. It kind of felt like she was being built up to be the investigative journalist that figures it all out, but in the end she doesn't, she just gets told the answer in Nora's effects after she dies.
Overall this book was relatively enjoyable to read, if somewhat slow, but very unsatisfying.