Amber Herbert reviewed King Sorrow by Joe Hill
Stephen King with Dragons
3 stars
King Sorrow is Stephen King with dragons. Fans of King (Joe Hill's father) will consider this a compliment. Those more critical of the master of horror might find that my comments of King Sorrow mirror their experience with It.
King Sorrow reeled me in with strong character building and a slow introduction to supernatural elements. Any scene with Arthur or Llewellyn was great, and I initially loved the college-aged Losers Club. But what began as a powerful introduction moved swiftly into a slumping middle. While the pacing of Books Two and Three limped along, my dislike for Allie, Van, and Donna only made it worse.
When I was about to throw in the towel, I met Arthur and Colin in Tintagel and the surrounding Cornwall area. Stu Finger and his cave were whimsical, intriguing, and colorful in a way that both excited and infuriated me. If Hill can …
King Sorrow is Stephen King with dragons. Fans of King (Joe Hill's father) will consider this a compliment. Those more critical of the master of horror might find that my comments of King Sorrow mirror their experience with It.
King Sorrow reeled me in with strong character building and a slow introduction to supernatural elements. Any scene with Arthur or Llewellyn was great, and I initially loved the college-aged Losers Club. But what began as a powerful introduction moved swiftly into a slumping middle. While the pacing of Books Two and Three limped along, my dislike for Allie, Van, and Donna only made it worse.
When I was about to throw in the towel, I met Arthur and Colin in Tintagel and the surrounding Cornwall area. Stu Finger and his cave were whimsical, intriguing, and colorful in a way that both excited and infuriated me. If Hill can write like this, I thought, why isn't the whole novel written with such care, poignancy, and concision?
Hill's character development was solid while occasionally repetitive. King Sorrow and the horrible Nightswanders felt like single characteristics personified. All but one death fell flat. Substantial hints were dropped before finding their way into a tense scene. While these criticisms could have faded into the background, it was impossible not to notice them when much of the novel dragged. Joe Hill is a good writer hindered by his popularity. Like Stephen King, a good editor could have tightened the prose, removed unnecessary sections, and imbued the story with more tension.
If you like Stephen King and Joe Hill's other works, I'm sure you'll enjoy King Sorrow. If you're seeking a long trek with urgency, evocative world building, well-constructed character arcs, and three-dimensional villains, I suggest looking elsewhere.













