Back

@aspensmonster Why?

Melanchon says “We Need a New Civic Morality”. Isn’t thutopian vision that says we don’t need to overthrow capitalism?

2022:
In a remarkable outburst, Mélenchon tartly told his supporters he would abandon them if they expected him to do better than third place: “Of course the younger ones will tell me, ‘So we haven’t gotten there yet.’ You think it’s not far away, huh? Well, do better yourselves, thank you.”
https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/04/13/mele-a13.html

@aspensmonster “if the ideas are sound, they will stand on their own”

Why are you talking abstract hypotheticals rather than discussing Melanchon‘s utopian ideas?

“Unsound ideas” that serve the interests of the ruling class arise all the time and they fought for with cunning, deceit, lies, force, violence and terror.

Sound ideas don’t fight for themselves.

FYI: many claim the label of Trotskyist. You should ask them to justify themselves. Most of them don’t deserve it.