Reviews and Comments

Aaron

awmarrs@bookwyrm.social

Joined 2 years, 5 months ago

Historian of antebellum technology and contemporary diplomacy.

Mastodon: historians.social/@awmarrs

This link opens in a pop-up window

America Last

Heilbrunn's book examines the American right wing's fascination with dictators throughout the twentieth century and up through the present day. The book reads like an accretion of anecdotes and stories -- all of which are interesting in their own right, but I did not get a sense of historical development or change. Rather, this appears to be one thing after another. Nevertheless, the evidence that Heilbrunn has amassed leaves no doubt that there is a significant right wing obscession with/appreciation for dictatorship, with Savimbi, Pinochet, Franco, Orban, Hitler and others all receiving praise from prominent Americans. A profoundly disturbing catalog of people's willingness to abandon democratic principles and values when tempted by the appearance of strength abroad.

Thi Bui: The Best We Could Do

The Best We Could Do

Early in the book, Thi Bui writes something to the effect that when it comes to family, proximity is not closeness. This remarkable book charts her discovery of her parents' story, particularly their lives in Vietnam and what they had to do in order to escape the country in the wake of the Vietnam War. For anyone who has parents, the story will resonate as she learns things about them that she never new. For Americans in particular, the book is instructive about how Vietnamese experienced the "Vietnam War," and were affected by changing demands of loyalty and shifts in power.

Michele Norris: Our Hidden Conversations (2024, Simon & Schuster)

Our Hidden Conversations

I wasn't familiar with Norris's race card project until my wife recommended this book. It is actually extraordinary to witness average Americans trying to distill their experience with race and racism into six words, and the people quoted here have come up with an astonishing variety of submissions. Norris has organized the submissions into themes and done extended conversations with many of the people who made submissions. Those deeper conversations round out the stories behind the six words they submitted, and chart the complexity of race in America. The end result is that we get both the blunt assessment of Americans on this issue, and the life stories that led them to their conclusions.

Han Kang, Han Kang: White Book (Hardcover, 2019, Crown/Archetype)

The White Book

In this novel, the narrator reflects on the death of her older sister, who died two hours after she was born. Their mother described the infant as "white as a crescent-moon cake." From that description, the narrator considers all the other ways that she has encountered the color white, and the emotions that they trigger in her about the sister that she never met. This capsule description doesn't do the novel justice, of course -- Kang thoroughly plumbs the emotional depths of the topic in moving and fascinating ways.

Eric Ries: The Lean Startup (Paperback, 2011, Crown Business)

"Most startups are built to fail. But those failures, according to entrepreneur Eric Ries, are …

The Lean Startup

Nothing too earth-shattering, but some good ideas in here about determining what type of data one should use to analyze operations (not just the data that makes you look good), as well as knowing when to push on vs. when to pivot.

reviewed The portrait of a lady by Henry James (A Norton critical edition)

Henry James: The portrait of a lady (1975, Norton)

Een rijke Amerikaanse jonge vrouw met een sterke drang naar onafhankelijkheid blijft, ondanks alles wat …

The Portrait of a Lady

This is the first novel by James that I have ever read, so I was not entirely sure what to expect. I enjoyed tremendously James's close attention to detail to the characters, their appearance, their surroundings, and the turmoil of their inner lives. James establishes early on the independence of the heroine, Isabel Archer. In this exchange, Isabel says:

"I always want to know the things one shouldn't do." "So as to do them?" asked her aunt. "So as to choose," said Isabel.

In rejecting her various suitors, Isabel is determined to live life in the way that she sees best and not peremptorily close off any possible routes. Do we need spoiler alerts for books published in 1881? Let's just say that things do not develop as Isabel intends, and James keeps the reader's interest by not closing off possible outcomes and carefully considering each character's actions and motivations.

David R. George III, Armin Shimerman: 34th Rule (2000, Simon & Schuster, Limited)

The 34th Rule

Armin Shimerman has noted that it was his "personal agenda" in DS9 to make the Ferengi a more three-dimensional race than they were portrayed in TNG (trekmovie.com/2018/03/21/armin-shimerman-feels-responsible-for-failed-ferengi-introduction-on-star-trek-the-next-generation/). This book might be seen as part of that effort, as Shimerman gives depth to Quark's interior life in this novel. But there's a lot more going on here than just one character. The novel sets up a conflict between Bajor and Ferenginar in an interesting way, contrasting their spiritual and materialistic societies. And we see some of the lasting horrors of the Cardassian occupation on Bajoran lives. Good moments for all the DS9 characters here, who Shimerman clearly knows inside and out. Weighs in at 450 pages, but I was never bored. Great book by an author clearly invested in the subject.

reviewed The heart of the warrior by John Gregory Betancourt (Star trek, deep space nine)

John Gregory Betancourt, John Betancourt: The heart of the warrior (Paperback, 1996, Pocket Books)

While a crucial peace conference fills Deep Space Nine with rumors of intrigue and conspiracy, …

The Heart of the Warrior

This is probably the least compelling of the DS9 books that I've read. Still a good yarn with a secret mission to the Gamma Quadrant and a host of aliens who can more easily exist in the imaginations of novelists than on screen. There's some good material here with a planet in the Gamma Quadrant. Glad I read it, but not top-shelf Trek.

Jessica Calarco: Holding It Together (2024, Penguin Publishing Group)

Holding it Together

Calarco brings together both heartbreaking anecdotes and reliable data to underscore how the uncompensated labor of women has become the de facto safety net in this country. She briefly traces the history of how businessmen fought to prevent the United States from having robust social protections. But for me the most damning part of the book are the interviews with husbands, who almost carelessly take their wives' labor for granted, all the while feigning admiration. Men, if you have ever said "I don't know how she does it," Calarco's riposte ("you could ask") should give you pause.

Han Kang: The Vegetarian (Hardcover, 2016, Hogarth)

Translation of Ch'aesikchuŭija (Published 2007 by Ch'angbi)

The Vegetarian

One of my favorite short stories which I read in college was Melville's "Bartleby, the Scrivner." But Bartleby's got nothing on Yeong-hye. Her decision to become a vegetarian sends her family into a tailspin, as Han explores how an effort to renounce violence and reject the world's demands provokes a more and more violent reaction from those around her. Aspects of the story are absurd, but are told in a straight, just-the-facts-ma'am style that heightens the sense of how stark (yet simple) Yeong-hye's actions are. She determines, for her own reasons, to live as she wants, and the novel illustrates how challenging it is to take such a stance.

Han Kang, Han Kang: Human Acts (Hardcover, 2017, Hogarth Press)

From the internationally bestselling author of “The Vegetarian,” a rare and astonishing (The Observer) portrait …

Human Acts

Han narrates, from multiple viewpoints and time periods, a 1980 uprising that was brutally put down by South Korea's military government. At the beginning of the book I was struck by how ordinary people banded together to help each other -- in this case, working tirelessly in a makeshift morgue to help families identify their loved ones, all the while listening for the army's return. Han evocatively carries the story through time and shows the lasting effects of the government's brutality. And yet, the novel also demonstrates that people can be moved to come together and fight for each other, even in the face of brutal, senseless violence.

Rhaina Cohen: The Other Significant Others (Hardcover, St. Martin's Press)

Why do we place romantic partnership on a pedestal? What do we lose when we …

The Other Significant Others

Not the book I thought it would be, but still an interesting and worthwhile read. Cohen explores several sets of friends whose bonds are close without passing over into romantic love. Her work illustrates how impoverished our language, legal structures, and social norms are when it comes to describing and honoring these types of bonds. The stories she tells demonstrate that deep friendship is possible and valuable, and just how hard people have worked to make it work. The payoff, in an enriched life that others may never fully understand, seems entirely worth it to all the people involved. The book may lead you to question some of the conventions which limit how we let others into our lives.

William Lee Miller: Arguing about Slavery (Hardcover, 1996, Alfred Knopf)

Arguing about Slavery

Miller's book is a good overview of the history of the gag rule, a story with complex parliamentary maneuvering that Miller tells with patience and good humor. He has mastered the intricacies that John Quincy Adams used to press the issue and those that Adams's opponents used to suppress the same. The book features many lengthy quotations to give a sense of the proceedings (and get a sense of Adams's acerbic wit), but the citation format will be frustrating to the serious researcher attempting to locate the materials.