Sachs's book is not strictly a biography of Schoenberg -- he acknowledges up front that there are other, more detailed treatments of Schoenberg's life out there -- but Sachs definitely hits the highlights, and, more importantly, explores the question of why this composer's music and philosophy had the impact that they did on the wider musical world. I don't think I've ever read a book that starts with "A Warning," in which Sachs states plainly that Schoenberg's music is rarely performed by major orchestras around the world. But reading the book it is clear that Schoenberg had an impact on everyone he met; no one came away from him indifferent. Sachs concludes that if we can make room for novels or visual arts that challenge the reader/viewer, then surely we can have challenging music as well. The catch, of course, is that music requires an intermediary (the musicians) in between …
User Profile
Historian of antebellum technology and contemporary diplomacy.
Mastodon: historians.social/@awmarrs
This link opens in a pop-up window
Aaron's books
Read (View all 139)
2025 Reading Goal
48% complete! Aaron has read 24 of 50 books.
User Activity
RSS feed Back
Aaron reviewed Schoenberg by Harvey Sachs
Schoenberg
4 stars
Sachs's book is not strictly a biography of Schoenberg -- he acknowledges up front that there are other, more detailed treatments of Schoenberg's life out there -- but Sachs definitely hits the highlights, and, more importantly, explores the question of why this composer's music and philosophy had the impact that they did on the wider musical world. I don't think I've ever read a book that starts with "A Warning," in which Sachs states plainly that Schoenberg's music is rarely performed by major orchestras around the world. But reading the book it is clear that Schoenberg had an impact on everyone he met; no one came away from him indifferent. Sachs concludes that if we can make room for novels or visual arts that challenge the reader/viewer, then surely we can have challenging music as well. The catch, of course, is that music requires an intermediary (the musicians) in between composer and listener; if no one wants to play the music, we won't hear it in the concert hall. But Schoenberg continues to have his advocates, and the place of his students Berg and Webern seems to be solid as well. The subtitle is a statement (why he matters), not a question (does he matter?) -- Schoenberg is a composer worth taking the time to listen to.
Aaron finished reading Heretic by Jeanna Kadlec

Heretic by Jeanna Kadlec
A memoir of leaving the evangelical church and the search for radical new ways to build community.
Jeanna Kadlec knew …
Aaron started reading Heretic by Jeanna Kadlec

Heretic by Jeanna Kadlec
A memoir of leaving the evangelical church and the search for radical new ways to build community.
Jeanna Kadlec knew …
Aaron started reading Arguing about Slavery by William Lee Miller
Aaron finished reading Schoenberg by Harvey Sachs
Aaron started reading Schoenberg by Harvey Sachs
Aaron reviewed End of Drum-Time by Hanna Pylväinen
End of Drum-Time
4 stars
Pylväinen's novel is a marvelous picture of mid-nineteenth century Scandinavia. There's a lot of rich material here, but what stuck out to me was the way in which the novel explores the multi-layered effects of colonialism. At one point the native people (the Sámi) argue about the potential effects of decisions made by distant kings on their livelihood as reindeer herders. They are hardly ignorant or oblivious of the wider world. Rather, they can see all too well the impact of the encroaching settlers. While a love story takes center stage in the novel, the wider world of natives, settlers, and the changes in international politics that create intended and unintended consequences are all part of Pylväinen's wider stage.
Aaron finished reading End of Drum-Time by Hanna Pylväinen
Aaron started reading End of Drum-Time by Hanna Pylväinen
Aaron reviewed James: A Novel by Percival Everett
James
5 stars
Some novels grab you immediately and refuse to let you go until you have read through to the last page. James is such a novel. It's brilliant, astonishing, and packs an emotional wallop. I haven't read Huckleberry Finn in over 30 years, so I have no idea how closely Everett tracked to that book -- but it is irrelevant. As a sharp, funny, heartbreaking examination of slavery and life in nineteenth century America, James stands on its own, whether you have read Huckleberry Finn or not.
Aaron finished reading James: A Novel by Percival Everett

James: A Novel by Percival Everett
When Jim overhears that he is about to be sold to a man in New Orleans, separated from his wife …
Aaron started reading James: A Novel by Percival Everett

James: A Novel by Percival Everett
When Jim overhears that he is about to be sold to a man in New Orleans, separated from his wife …
Aaron reviewed Wandering Stars by Tommy Orange
Wandering Stars
4 stars
Wandering Stars is a novel that covers several generations of the family that featured in his first novel, There, There, although it is not necessary to have read that book to understand this one. The bulk of Wandering Stars focuses on the present generation, but the early chapters make explicit the fact that the later characters are still grappling with the appalling legacy of how Native Americans have been treated over centuries. Orange moves among different perspectives with ease, with some characters speaking directly to the reader in first person, and other chapters provided by an omniscient narrator. Orange has a gift for capturing small yet meaningful interactions between people, and writing eloquently how we support each other (not always willingly, not always perfectly), through grief, addiction, and loss.
Aaron finished reading Wandering Stars by Tommy Orange

Wandering Stars by Tommy Orange
Colorado, 1864. Star, a young survivor of the Sand Creek Massacre, is brought to the Fort Marion prison castle,where he …