User Profile

bgainor

bgainor@bookwyrm.social

Joined 3 months, 4 weeks ago

Programmer with a linguistics background, dad, trekkie. He/him Mastodon: @bgainor@mstdn.party

This link opens in a pop-up window

bgainor's books

Currently Reading

A. R. Moxon: Very Fine People (2024, J. Goat Press) No rating

What is the price to be paid for an uneducated population?

What is the price to be paid for a nation that won’t care for those in need?

What is the price to be paid for potential ungrasped?

What is the price to be paid for a nation of desperate people?

What bill will come eventually due because a country has been destabilized by invasion and occupation and warfare, what bill will come due if a population is made desperate by need?

Very Fine People by  (Page 73)

A. R. Moxon: Very Fine People (2024, J. Goat Press) No rating

I submit that a casual observer can tell a lot about a society by observing how, when, and why it prioritizes justice over order, or order over justice. If a society is unjust, an insistence on a more perfect justice is not going to view the natural disruption to order that restoring justice will bring as a bad thing. Not because the society hates order, but because it has determined that order must first demand justice—otherwise it is going to be an ordered injustice, a terrible order not worth the cost it will levy upon the soul and conscience. But if a society prefers order above justice, it’s going to focus on the particulars of the existing rules that support that order, with little consideration as to whether or not those rules establish justice; and those who prioritize order are going to ignore and suppress and dismantle any rules that do not support that unjust order. Not necessarily because they hate justice (though some clearly do), but because they recognize that establishing a more perfect justice will necessarily require a great disruption to their desired order, a terrible price they deem to not be worth the cost to stability and prosperity.

Very Fine People by  (Page 56 - 57)

A. R. Moxon: Very Fine People (2024, J. Goat Press) No rating

It’s worth pondering why every call for civility is issued for the benefit of those who have dedicated their lives to incivility. It’s worth pondering why every call for healing centers on those who have done the harming. It’s worth pondering why the people who cry the loudest about our divisiveness and political incivility never direct their laments at the people who elected a corrupt and mean racist bully.

Very Fine People by  (Page 54)

A. R. Moxon: Very Fine People (2024, J. Goat Press) No rating

I’ve heard the same line again and again since the election: “America isn’t a different country today than it was before the election.” Jon Stewart trotted it out. I think I heard it from President Obama. I fear I agree with the statement. I’m puzzled, though, because I think it is meant to be reassuring, to think we’ve always been the country capable of such a choice.

To me, this statement doesn’t imply that we’re still great.

It implies that we were never good.

Very Fine People by  (Page 31)

A. R. Moxon: Very Fine People (2024, J. Goat Press) No rating

Some people thought he would be less likely to make them pay more in taxes, I suppose. So perhaps at last now we know the answer to the old hypothetical about whether we’d be willing to travel through time and sacrifice our lives to prevent the rise of a self-professing tyrant. Answer: We wouldn’t even suffer a hypothetical increase in our income taxes.

Very Fine People by  (Page 30)

Willa Cather: Death Comes for the Archbishop (1971, Vintage)

In 1851 French Bishop Latour and his friend Father Valliant are dispatched to New Mexico …

Mixed bag

This book has a lot of lovely descriptions of the landscape of New Mexico, some very interesting characterizations, and a lot of nice turns of phrase. But as @gwenprime@bookwyrm.social noted, it's very much a book of its time. In particular, the fact that Kit Carson is featured as a (mostly) sympathetic character feels very inappropriate from a modern perspective. I believe that in the 1920s, its sympathetic portrayal of Native Americans and the Long Walk of the Navajo was pretty progressive, but a lot of it now seems rather paternalistic. Worth reading as long as you can keep all that in mind.

Willa Cather: Death Comes for the Archbishop (1971, Vintage)

In 1851 French Bishop Latour and his friend Father Valliant are dispatched to New Mexico …

“I am not deprecating your individual talent, Joseph,” the Bishop continued, “but, when one thinks of it, a soup like this is not the work of one man. It is the result of a constantly refined tradition. There are nearly a thousand years of history in this soup.”

Death Comes for the Archbishop by  (Vintage Books) (14%)