Reviews and Comments

bwaber

bwaber@bookwyrm.social

Joined 2 months, 3 weeks ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

Accounting for Slavery offers a history of business and management practices on slave plantations in …

A Powerful Investigation into the Connections between Modern Business and Management Practices and Slavery

5 stars

Most management textbooks start with a review of "scientific management," but Rosenthal demonstrates why scholars should look back farther to the slave plantations of the 18th and 19th century for the genesis of modern approaches to accounting and management. Using volumes of historical records, this book shows how the slave plantation industry developed sophisticated methods to control and measure every aspect of their plantation, including their slaves. There are direct lines from these practices to the development of org charts and time and motion studies - Henry Gantt of Gantt chart fame, for example, grew up in a family that had grown rich from owning slaves and almost certainly used these same management methods.

All of this cries out for a reckoning with different management practices that have become commonplace - individual work measurement, the myopic focus on easy to measure quantitative metrics, etc. If you're in management or people …

Andrew W. Lo: The Evolution of Technical Analysis (2010) 4 stars

An Intriguing History of Financial Series Prediction

4 stars

While many modern economists push back against the idea that one can make money from projecting forward past market trends (which Lo and Hasanhodzic push back against in later chapters), given market frictions in the past this was much more plausible. Commodity prices could take weeks or months to propagate to other regions, making prediction profitable and immensely challenging. This book charts the mystical roots of these predictions in early history, moving towards more data-driven and accurate approaches developed in Japan and a few other areas in more recent centuries.

The tight coupling of technological changes with new methods of technical analysis is generally instructive, having implications for many other industries and practices that rely on arbitrage, market power, or gut instinct to drive decisions. Highly recommend

Timothy P. Hubbard, Harry J. Paarsch: Auctions (2016, MIT Press) 4 stars

An Insightful Look at the Economics of Auctions

4 stars

If you want to gain a good, introductory level understanding of the economic underpinnings of different types of auctions this is the book. Hubbard and Paarsch distill volumes of research into methodical examinations of optimality and strategies in different auction types, when these types of auctions are useful, and what factors tend to influence their outcomes. If there's a gap here it's in the sidelining of psychology and irrationality that humans exhibit. There is some discussion of that when considering auction types whose rules are too complex, but I would've liked to see that get a bit more coverage.

That being said, auctions are an essential economic structure that influences many areas of business and society today. I highly recommend this book as a solid first step into understanding them

Walter A. Friedman: American Business History (2020, Oxford University Press, Incorporated) 4 stars

A Rapid-Fire History of the US Economy

3 stars

Friedman has compiled an impressive review of the history of US business, including excellent although fairly brief acknowledgements of the centrality of Native Americans and slavery in building the US into the economic power it is today. I was hoping for more examination of the roots of different business practices, and while they are mentioned here - stock-based acquisitions, organizational hierarchies, franchising, etc. - as with most things in this book it's quickly on to the next event.

Obviously the title says it all - "a very short introduction." For research and reference purposes this book is excellent, but don't expect to come out with deep insight into the evolution of American business.

Karen Levy: Data Driven (2022, Princeton University Press) 4 stars

A Deep Dive Into the Frontline of Workplace Surveillance and Automation

4 stars

When it comes to the promise and perils of workplace surveillance and automation, long distance trucking is the canary in the coal mine. Uniquely positioned as a highly regulated, supposedly easily quantifiable workplace, the mandated rollout of electronic logging devices in trucks has significantly transformed the industry. Through rigorous ethnographic analysis Levy pulls open the curtain on this critical but oft-overlooked industry, exposing the issues with technological solutionism and the problems with focusing workplace measurement and improvements on the easy to measure rather than more systemic issues.

For folks in the people analytics field especially this is required reading, as long distance trucking almost certainly makes these more systemic problems easier to detect than in most other workplaces. While I would've liked a bit more economic analysis here, overall I highly recommend this book

Michael Tomasello: Becoming Human (2019, Belknap Press: An Imprint of Harvard University Press) 5 stars

A Research-Driven Comparison of Human and Chimp/Bonobo Development

5 stars

As humans, we like to think that we're radically different than other animals. When it comes to our closest living relatives, however, it is often quite challenging to articulate our precise differences. Tomasello dives into the vast pool of fascinating experimental academic research in this area, taking us through stages of human and ape cognitive, social, and cultural development through childhood to illuminate uniquely human traits and their importance is our rise to global dominance.

Tomasello deftly marries readability with academic rigor, which I've found to be extremely rare. It doesn't hurt that the experiments themselves are ingenious and often accompanied by hilarious quotes from small children. If you're at all interested in child development, evolution, or cognition, this is a must read. Highly recommend

"Rodrik takes globalization's cheerleaders to task, not for emphasizing economics over other values, but for …

An Informed But Mostly Opinion-Laden Tour through the Political Economy of Modern Economic Policy

3 stars

This book provides a thorough rebuke of the neoliberal economic consensus that drove global economic policy from 1980 to around 2016, although much more on ideological grounds alone rather than grounded in much data or rigorous analysis. That's not to say the conclusions are wrong - far from it. Most are almost certainly correct, although with the exception of an excellent chapter on moving the field of economics to a focus on identifying the correct models for the correct economic problem much of the rest of the book is left for the reader to fill in the blanks.

As a consequence, if you're unfamiliar with the last ~8 years of cutting-edge economic research, you may wonder which of the suppositions Rodrik expounds on are justified and to what degree they explain many of the local and global economic disparities that are observed today. If you want that kind of analysis, …