frenchcookie49 reviewed The gods are thirsty by Tanith Lee
I'm sorry, when did Antoine Saint Just get to Paris???
2 stars
Why are books written English about the French Revolutionary Camille Desmoulins and his wife Lucile Desmoulins always so, so, so bad?
Like this is one where it's not even "well if your an expert you'll be annoyed" this is very basic stuff in the timeliness of where people are and when. Like for example why is Saint-Just in Paris in 1791??? He was still living at home in Decize at the time. And this a basic information you wouldn't need wikipedia for sine he very notably WROTE A LETTER TO ROBESPIERRE FROM THERE IN 1791!!
But this is a microcosm of French rev literature really. This, the Scarlett Pimpernel, A Tale Of Two Cities, and fucking my arch enemy- A Place Of Greater Safety. English speakers have more or less decided they can just make up whatever about the Revolution of 89 and call it good.
One star for the …
Why are books written English about the French Revolutionary Camille Desmoulins and his wife Lucile Desmoulins always so, so, so bad?
Like this is one where it's not even "well if your an expert you'll be annoyed" this is very basic stuff in the timeliness of where people are and when. Like for example why is Saint-Just in Paris in 1791??? He was still living at home in Decize at the time. And this a basic information you wouldn't need wikipedia for sine he very notably WROTE A LETTER TO ROBESPIERRE FROM THERE IN 1791!!
But this is a microcosm of French rev literature really. This, the Scarlett Pimpernel, A Tale Of Two Cities, and fucking my arch enemy- A Place Of Greater Safety. English speakers have more or less decided they can just make up whatever about the Revolution of 89 and call it good.
One star for the threesome and one star for audacity.