ZodWallop reviewed Darkness Below by Barbara Cottrell (The Shadows of Miskatonic, #1)
Harry Potter in Lovecraft drag
2 stars
Lovecraft's most famous story, The Call of Cthulhu, starts with: "The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents." His stories almost always dealt with researchers finding out more than they bargained for. Knowledge of the existence of the Great Old Ones was enough to destroy sanity.
Darkness Below had none of that. Arkham and Miskatonic University are treated as places where Sabrina the teenage witch would have felt at home. Kooky, witchy and hiply supernatural. Students regularly perform rituals and seem to have no problem dealing with creatures from beyond. The book is more fantasy than horror and just wasn't for me. It's not even fantasy so much as romantasy.
Lovecraft's baroque and florid descriptive prose is replaced by a breezy, fast paced narrative that rarely takes the time to describe what anything looks like. …
Lovecraft's most famous story, The Call of Cthulhu, starts with: "The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents." His stories almost always dealt with researchers finding out more than they bargained for. Knowledge of the existence of the Great Old Ones was enough to destroy sanity.
Darkness Below had none of that. Arkham and Miskatonic University are treated as places where Sabrina the teenage witch would have felt at home. Kooky, witchy and hiply supernatural. Students regularly perform rituals and seem to have no problem dealing with creatures from beyond. The book is more fantasy than horror and just wasn't for me. It's not even fantasy so much as romantasy.
Lovecraft's baroque and florid descriptive prose is replaced by a breezy, fast paced narrative that rarely takes the time to describe what anything looks like. I never felt emotionally invested in the text. Never felt for the characters, never felt the atmosphere of any of the ostensibly creepy places we visit. The book just left me cold.
The characters are fairly flat and behave as they must on order to move the plot along. The main character, Ellen, is a rich, good-looking and confident blonde who is treated as a social pariah for no reason I could see except that it fit the narrative.
Her sparring partner/love interest is the charming dickhead teacher Andrew Carter. He acts as expected.
We're introduced to a friend of Carter's, Connie something. I thought 'oh, this guy will take Ellen under his wing and introduce her to Carter's world.' Instead, he unexpectedly becomes a hateful jerk for reasons that were murky at best.
I didn't like the characters, didn't like the writing and didn't like the story. That cover is pretty awesome though.












