Reading Tintin with my kiddo has been a strange experience. I'd never read any Tintin before, but thought it sounded like a much-loved set of adventures that my six year old might like.
And he does love them! But it's been a bit bemusing, from an adult perspective. Firstly, the quality of the narrative swings wildly back and forth, but not so much that I can't enjoy the tale along with him. All part of the fun.
Sometimes we have to pause the reading while I embark on quite extravagant explanations, because some of the plot twists aren't explicitly spelled out to a six year old's comprehension, but that's fine. I like an excuse to chat while we read.
While I'm on the subject of age-appropriateness though, I should mention that all the tales are littered with explicit references to fairly adult themes. The tale's baddies are often gun runners …
User Profile
This link opens in a pop-up window
Jonathan Hartley's books
User Activity
RSS feed Back
Jonathan Hartley rated Echopraxia: 5 stars

Echopraxia by Peter Watts (Firefall, #2)
A follow-up to the Hugo Award-nominated Blindsight, Echopraxia is set in a 22nd-century world transformed by scientific evangelicals, supernatural beings …
Jonathan Hartley rated Revelation Space: 2 stars
Jonathan Hartley rated Pattern recognition: 4 stars

Pattern recognition by William Gibson, William F. Gibson (duplicate) (Blue Ant, #1)
One of the most influential and imaginative writers of the past twenty years turns his attention to London - with …
Jonathan Hartley rated Bradbury Stories: 5 stars

Bradbury Stories by Ray Bradbury
Bradbury Stories: 100 of His Most Celebrated Tales (2003) is a collection of short stories by Ray Bradbury. Bradbury wrote …
Jonathan Hartley rated Little, Big: 4 stars

Little, Big by John Crowley
John Crowley's masterful Little, Big is the epic story of Smoky Barnable, an anonymous young man who travels by foot …
Jonathan Hartley rated Behemoth: 4 stars
Jonathan Hartley rated Halting state: 2 stars

Halting state by Charles Stross
In the year 2018, a daring bank robbery has taken place at Hayek Associates. The suspects are a band of …
Jonathan Hartley rated Ready Player One: 1 star

Ready Player One by Ernest Cline
Ready Player One is a 2011 science fiction novel, and the debut novel of American author Ernest Cline. The story, …
Jonathan Hartley reviewed Tintin in America by Hergé (His The adventures of Tintin)
Review of 'Tintin in America' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
Reading Tintin with my kiddo has been a strange experience. I'd never read any Tintin before, but thought it sounded like a much-loved set of adventures that my six year old might like.
And he does love them! But it's been a bit bemusing, from an adult perspective. Firstly, the quality of the narrative swings wildly back and forth, but not so much that I can't enjoy the tale along with him. All part of the fun.
Sometimes we have to pause the reading while I embark on quite extravagant explanations, because some of the plot twists aren't explicitly spelled out to a six year old's comprehension, but that's fine. I like an excuse to chat while we read.
While I'm on the subject of age-appropriateness though, I should mention that all the tales are littered with explicit references to fairly adult themes. The tale's baddies are often gun runners or drug-smugglers. Tintin's investigations lead him to infiltrate heroin dens, at which patrons are depicted on thin floor mattresses with adjacent paraphernalia. Captain Haddock's alcoholism is a real problem, and sometimes Snowy the dog gets a taste for the whisky too, with tragi-comic consequences. People (including Tintin) shoot guns at each other, which trembles my delicate English sensibilities. But while this is often without result, it isn't gratuitous - at one point Tintin ends up hospitalized as a result.
However, it's probably these forays into strange and exciting topics that gives it half its thrill, so we're going to continue with it - although I'm sure some others would choose not to.
Meanwhile, there are so many tales that, together with the other volumes, Tintin will last us literally dozens of weeks of bedtime reading - the sort of long-term exposure that no doubt resulted in the golden nostalgia with which adults of today regard Tintin.
Jonathan Hartley rated The Righteous Mind: 5 stars

The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt
Why can’t our political leaders work together as threats loom and problems mount? Why do people so readily assume the …
Jonathan Hartley rated Totally Wired: 5 stars
Jonathan Hartley rated Beyond the rift: 5 stars

Beyond the rift by Peter Watts
Combining complex science with skillfully executed prose, these edgy, award-winning tales explore the shifting border between the known and the …
Jonathan Hartley rated Wool: 5 stars

Wool by Hugh Howey (Silo, #1)
They live beneath the earth in a prison of their own making. There is a view of the outside world, …