Reviews and Comments

urbaer

urbaer@bookwyrm.social

Joined 3 years, 6 months ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

Review of 'The Hanging Tree: The Sixth PC Grant Mystery' on 'GoodReads'

4 stars

Getting near the end of the book, was worried that it was going to wrap up too much, but seems to have kept a lot of stuff unanswered (while answering some questions) and adding more to the world. Now I presume a long agonising wait for the next book...

Geronimo travels to Egypt to interview Professor Alrat Spitfur and learns the secret of the …

Review of 'Geronimo Stilton The Curse of the Cheese Pyramid' on 'GoodReads'

3 stars

We enjoyed the first book more. This one had a lot of stuff to teach the young ones about Egyptian history, but the plot is almost non-existent. Geronimo spends so little time in Egypt and there's not much adventuring elsewhere.

Hopefully the series picks up from here.

reviewed The castle of Llyr by Lloyd Alexander (Chronicles of Prydain -- 3)

Lloyd Alexander: The castle of Llyr (Paperback, 1999, H. Holt) 4 stars

When Princess Eilonwy is sent to the Isle of Mona for training, she is bewitched …

Review of 'The castle of Llyr' on 'GoodReads'

No rating

Having read Taran Wanderer many times and seen The Black Cauldron movie more, it's great to see what happened between the two (I'm now going to presume that I remember Taran Wanderer well enough to skip ahead to The High King)

Terry Pratchett: The Shepherd's Crown: Number 41 of the Discworld Novels Series (Hardcover, 2015, Doubleday UK) 4 stars

The final Discworld novel.

Review of "The Shepherd's Crown: Number 41 of the Discworld Novels Series" on 'GoodReads'

No rating

So here's the thing... I'm not going to rate this one mostly because I have mixed feelings about the book which are almost entirely due to the fact that it's not finished. I mean it has an ending, yes, but it wasn't up to the spit and polish that we expect from a Discworld novel.

But that's not the story's fault and it's not Sir Terry's fault it's just the way things are. So it doesn't feel fair to rate it. Would I be rating it or the entire works of Sir Terry or the Discworld series as a whole... I don't know.