EMR reviewed The Dragons of Eden by Carl Sagan
Review of 'The Dragons of Eden' on 'Goodreads'
2 stars
Maybe this book was exciting when it came out, but I wouldn't recommend it at this time. Science and technology have moved on and many of the ideas he references are dated. Much of his exposition rests on the now discredited Triune Brain theory. But some parts don't even need new science to contradict them, they contradict themselves! For example, he speculates that sleep is an adaptation of mammals to avoid nocturnal predators... Which are themselves mammals and also sleep, they just sleep during the day. How does that make sense? He even admits that modern mammals which are also nocturnal predators (ie cats) do sleep a lot, but regards it as a vestigial trait and not contradictory to his theory. What?
The tie ins with mythology are neat but not explored in much depth. In fact that is a general theme of this work; refer to some neat thing …
Maybe this book was exciting when it came out, but I wouldn't recommend it at this time. Science and technology have moved on and many of the ideas he references are dated. Much of his exposition rests on the now discredited Triune Brain theory. But some parts don't even need new science to contradict them, they contradict themselves! For example, he speculates that sleep is an adaptation of mammals to avoid nocturnal predators... Which are themselves mammals and also sleep, they just sleep during the day. How does that make sense? He even admits that modern mammals which are also nocturnal predators (ie cats) do sleep a lot, but regards it as a vestigial trait and not contradictory to his theory. What?
The tie ins with mythology are neat but not explored in much depth. In fact that is a general theme of this work; refer to some neat thing for a paragraph then drop it. Discuss a real study for a paragraph then idle speculation for three or four more. The napkin calculations are also hilarious. He tries to design a study to measure the bandwidth of the human visual processing system in a pretty bananas way, measures it (n=1) then declares victory and starts comparing it to things.