This was a book club book I am left with many mixed feelings about it. The organization and format is absolutely horrid! The story itself had to be sifted and filtered out through the many mini-thoughts/explanations/inserts. It's about two men who each lost a daughter to violence in Israel/Palestine (10 years apart), and they each had to find a way to both deal with it and help heal the entire situation for themselves and others. The methods of dealing are admirable, but the overall thing – both grief and the entire situation – is miserable. I know that the overall rating of this book is pretty good, and there were even to members of our book club who really liked it, but the rest of us found the torment and organization too distracting at best.
A lot of what appealed to me about this book is the structure and the meta-fictional tricks. Exactly up my alley. I couldn’t help getting the occasional whiff of Richard Powers and the quotes from Borges were there, but in a “I know I’m not Borges so I’m not going to pretend” kind of way. This is perhaps the only way to tell the kind of stories McCann sets out to tell here.
This is a transcendental novel.returnreturnIt expands over the regular, over nuance, and over time. It also bends fiction and nonfiction to weave several arcs into one, not that it makes this book difficult or complicated.returnreturnThe book focuses on the friendship between an Israeli man and a Palestinian man, their respective deaths in the families, and of how life works for most people; I'm being fuzzy, but the bookâas well as human lifeâis; this book throws more nuance into the picture than most do, which is quite a feat, considering that this is all about human beings in Palestine and Israel.returnreturnThis book engrossed and changed me. It's that big.returnreturnThere are no other words that I can use to review the book other than say it's very human and beautifully pieced together; the book consists of 1,001 chapters. It's a marvellous and daring feat to write a book in this way, but …
This is a transcendental novel.returnreturnIt expands over the regular, over nuance, and over time. It also bends fiction and nonfiction to weave several arcs into one, not that it makes this book difficult or complicated.returnreturnThe book focuses on the friendship between an Israeli man and a Palestinian man, their respective deaths in the families, and of how life works for most people; I'm being fuzzy, but the bookâas well as human lifeâis; this book throws more nuance into the picture than most do, which is quite a feat, considering that this is all about human beings in Palestine and Israel.returnreturnThis book engrossed and changed me. It's that big.returnreturnThere are no other words that I can use to review the book other than say it's very human and beautifully pieced together; the book consists of 1,001 chapters. It's a marvellous and daring feat to write a book in this way, but consider how human thought is mostly led up different twists and turns. We're all kinetic in thought and act and this book reflects this. It also provides solace, meditation, thinking, while providing ethics, morals, thoughts, invasion, hatred, war, anger, forgiveness, and, foremost, understanding.returnreturnUnderstanding for each other. This is also why the book serves a very important purpose. It goes beyond where many books even are predestined to go.returnreturn
A rubber bullet, when shot from a metal tube on the end of an M-16, leaves the barrel of the gun at more than one hundred miles per hour. The bullets are large enough to be seen but too fast to be avoided. They were tested first in Northern Ireland, where the British called them knee-knockers: they were designed to be fired at the ground, then bounce up and hit the legs of rioters.
returnreturn
The soldiers called the bullets Lazarus pills: when possible, they could be picked up and used again.
returnreturn
The room had two large sofas, a long table and eight red chairs. Nobody took the sofas at first. They sat at opposite ends of the table. The language that they might use for each other was already fraught: Muslim, Arab, Christian, Jew, soldier, terrorist, fighter, martyr, occupier, occupied.
returnreturn
An hour slid by. The Israelis leaned into the table. One of them had, he said, been a pilot. Another, a paratrooper. One had spent much of his service as a commander at the Qalandia checkpoint. They had been in the forces, yes, but they had begun to speak out: against the Occupation, humiliation, murder, torture. Bassam sat stunned. He had never heard an Israeli mention such words before. He was certain they were on an operation. Intelligence, surveillance, an undercover ploy. What confused him was that one of them, Yehuda, looked like a settler. Stout and spectacled, with a long beard. Even his hair wore the mark of a kippah. Yehuda had been an officer in Hebron. He had, he said, begun to rethink it all, the conscription, the operations, all the talk of a moral army. Bassam leaned back in his chair and scowled. Why would they send such a glaring ruse? What kind of mockery was this? Perhaps, he thought, it was a form of double-think, triple-think: the Israelis were known for it, their mesmerizing chess, their theater, intricate and ruthless.
returnreturn
There are two to three seconds of consciousness after decapitation when the brain is still functioning: the mouth can make a sound and there can be ocular movement, a twitching of the eyeball or the openingâor closingâof an eyelid. It is said that decapitated men often look surprised as their bodies separate from their heads: as if their final thoughts are in flight, visions of loved ones in Stockholm, in Savannah, in Sierra Leone, in so many small and scattered Samarias.
returnreturn
Once, during Salman Rushdieâs fatwa, the Indian novelist received a single pebble in the mail, alone in a white envelope with no note included. The pebble sat on his desk for years until a New York house-cleaner mistakenly swept it up and threw it away.
returnreturn
The Kabbalists, in their attempt to examine the nature of the divine, are known to envision two aspects of God. The first, known as Ein Sof, finds God to be transcendent, unknowable, impersonal, endless and infinite. The second aspect is accessible to human perception, revealing the divine in the material world, available in our finite lives. Far from contradicting each other, the two aspects of the divineâ one locatable, one infiniteâare said to be perfectly complementary to one another, a form of deep truth to be found in apparent opposites.returnreturnBorges, too, was fascinated by the Kabbalah. He suggested that the world might merely be a system of symbols and that the universe, including the stars, was a manifestation of Godâs secret handwriting.returnreturnBorges wrote that it only takes two facing mirrors to form a labyrinth.
returnreturn
As a teenager, Bassam learned to carry an onion in his pocket to combat the scorch of tear gas in his lungs.
returnreturn
The Czech composer and pianist Rafael Schächter was held at the camp in Theresienstadt where he managed to smuggle in a legless upright piano. It was kept, at first, in a basement. Schächter conducted a chorus of Jewish musicians in sixteen performances of Giuseppe Verdiâs Requiem. The musicians learned the intricate music from a single vocal score. Schächter was interested in keeping the camp morale high. The performances were attended by senior Nazis and guards who, at the end, gave standing ovations. The final performance came during Operation Embellishment when excerpts of the Requiem were played for the Danish government officials and the Red Cross, after which Schächter was loaded in a railroad cattle car and shipped off to Auschwitz where he, like the filmmaker Kurt Gerron, heard the pellets dropping down through the grates in the ceiling.returnreturnAfter Schächterâs final performance, Eichmann is reported to have said: Those crazy Jews, singing their own requiem.
returnreturn
And you know, you just know, deep in your heart, by the way the nurses look at you, by the way the policemen shake their heads, by their hesitance, by the silences, you know, but you wonât admit it. You do this for many long hours until eventually, very late at night, you and your wife find yourselves in the morgue.