3.5 stars
I received this book for free, this does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
He smiled, and the dazzling force of it close up rocked Gareth in his seat. “You’re London, then? Nice to meet you, London.”
Gareth smiled back, hopelessly enthralled. “You too, Kent.”
After heated eye contact that lead to a week of secret rendezvouses, Gareth is devastated and hurt when “Kent” tells him he's leaving the London area to go back home. With a father that abandoned him to his uncaring uncle after his mother's death when he was six, Gareth leans into that childhood pain and feels unwanted and unloved all over again. Even though Kent is trying to tell him he still wants to meet up when he's in town, Gareth can't hear him and breaks it off with hurtful words.
Two days later, Gareth learns of his father's death and has inherited his Baronet, this has him traveling to Romney Marsh where he discovers his father's mistress, a half-sister, and that he has unwittingly followed Kent.
“This is the Marsh,” Catherine had said, and as so often, that was all the explanation there was.
The Secret Lives of Country Gentlemen was a more quiet and reflective toned story, even though it had mystery, suspense, and open door scenes. When Gareth gets to the Marsh, his feeling as an outsider is exacerbated as everyone looks at him as “outmarsh”. Catherine, his father's mistress is kind to him but she's also dependent on his generosity as she has no where else to go and his half-sister Cecy is an emotional seventeen year old who swings from wanting to build a relationship with him to angry when he doesn't do exactly as she wants. When Gareth unthinkingly tells someone he saw a group of smugglers, especially a female one, he gets pulled into testifying, trying to get on Cecy's good-side as she is seeing a Revenue officer. Ignoring warnings that informing on the Doomsday smuggling group will make him many Marsh enemies, Gareth thinks he's doing the right thing but when Josiah Doomsday steps into the court room and threatens to tell his own secrets, to save his sister Sophy, who Gareth is testifying he saw, Gareth has to back-down in front of everyone, because Josiah is Kent.
“You threatened me,” Sir Gareth said, low and savage. “You used—what we did.” He whispered that last.
As you can imagine, Gareth is raging angry, this breaks the fragile bond he was starting to build with Cecy and Josiah used an extremely dangerous and emotional secret against him. The hurt, also from Josiah on how Gareth broke things off, and anger do get talked through and Gareth works through his father abandonment issues. The plot also forces these two to have to work together, so by the half-way point, they're together, if still tentative. With the initial breaking apart and coming together mostly dealt with, Gareth learns that his father was receiving mysterious payments every month from somewhere and with Josiah saying that he had no smuggling deals with the man, men coming into Doomsday territory to frighten and harass Gareth and Cecy, and Gareth's uncle and cousin suddenly wanting to stay at his home with him, they start to investigate together to work out what is going on.
“Because you’re a smuggler and I’m a baronet. You’re Joss Doomsday and I’m outmarsh. I informed against your sister and you blackmailed me in public!” One argument might have been convincing; three was the opposite. Three was encouraging, even.
“Eh, details,” Joss said. “You still haven’t given me a good reason.”
This had a large cast of characters, the Doomsday family is many and Josiah also has to deal with some family dynamic business, mainly an uncle who feels he should be in charge. A rival, different territory smuggling group, Sweetwater, also comes into play and you have a good amount of moving pieces to keep track of. While I appreciated the detail to naming the places the characters were going, the place names became too many in conjunction with all the characters I was trying to keep track of. I thought it was a sweet, emotional layer to Gareth's character when he takes his father's incomplete naturalist (book cover tie-in!) studying notes and walks the marsh following in his father's footsteps to try and know the man better but it also gets a little lost in all the other moving pieces. Josiah had a few in depth moments, his talk with his granda, but for the most part, his character was on the move a lot and I wanted more settled moments with him.
“I missed you so much.” It was a whisper.
The last twenty percent brings all the plot threads together, Josiah having to once and for all deal with his uncle, Gareth also dealing with his uncle, and the mystery of the smuggling business Gareth's father was maybe involved in; the seemingly separate threads all weaved together in the end. There was also a quick, and again, I think got lost in the other going-on, character depth moment of Gareth giving us a third act break-up because of emotional growth he needed to do. As I said, a good amount of moving pieces, some economic class and warfare serving country versus community talk, a romance that was a little too quick developed for me, a few, almost got buried in the mix emotional depth moments, but all told with a care to language that really helped set the atmosphere.
