Back

commented on Knights of Sidonia, Vol. 3 by Tsutomu Nihei (Knights of Sidonia, #3)

Tsutomu Nihei: Knights of Sidonia, Vol. 3 (Paperback, 2013, Vertical) 2 stars

Heretofore unwilling to communicate in all but the most zero-sum fashion, humanity’s implacable nemesis attempts …

Quite ambivalent about it after 3+ volumes.

On one hand, the story is clearly not coasting: in each volume Something Happens (somebody dies or is significantly changed, or we learn more about the lore).

On the other hand: there were several times where I wondered whether some pages were missing, the transitions from one scene to another could have been better. I often don't understand exactly what's happening in action sequences. Also the story doesn't escape some tired tropes: the hero has amazing skills thanks to his lineage, and a lot of female/third-gender characters are attracted to him for no apparent reason. They're also naked or almost naked at some point. The characters look a lot like each other. Even a grandmother looks like a teenager.

After having read several other mangas by Tsutomu Nihei, it's fun to find new iterations of previous elements though: the gaunas, Toha Heavy Industries, the ominous masks, a bear...

@Llaverac I do find the action reads more clearly as the series wears on. Totally agree that it's disjointed for the first third.

The fan service elements are ultimately why this was his most commercially successful work and while I don't like it, I don't begrudge it either.

Even a grandmother looks like a teenager. This does get addressed!