I found the writing…fine, the worldbuilding unsatisfying (none of these kids ever picked up a newspaper?), and the plot slightly contrived. A good book! and still very touching! but one that I had expected more from based on everything I’d heard about it
Review of 'Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
By the same author as "Remains of the Day", this book is also about regret and lost opportunity and the ephemeral nature of happiness and love. From the title and the tone of the early book you might think this is a light romance or coming of age story, but it isn't really. It's dystopian fiction just as much as Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale", though you don't realize the full picture until late in the book. It would be better to read this without any advance spoilers, so I'll just say that if you enjoyed the gently wistful, regretful tone of "Remains of the Day" you'll probably enjoy this also.
Review of 'Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
I was totally and completely spoiled about this book (stupid movie previews), but that didn't prevent it from being one of the best books I've ever read.
At first, I wasn't sure how I felt about the narrative voice. Kath, the narrator, relays her story in a roughly chronological order, with many tangents and anecdotes. But over time, it builds on itself and becomes the poignant reflections of someone who is facing her own mortality and has also lost everyone and every place that meant anything to her living through her memories. There are several times that Kath reflects on situations that, despite the sadness or finality, took on a closeness and levity that is only possible in the types of friendships where you can simply have wandering conversations about anything. It is clear that Kath is speaking to a reader who is that kind of friend.
The larger plot …
I was totally and completely spoiled about this book (stupid movie previews), but that didn't prevent it from being one of the best books I've ever read.
At first, I wasn't sure how I felt about the narrative voice. Kath, the narrator, relays her story in a roughly chronological order, with many tangents and anecdotes. But over time, it builds on itself and becomes the poignant reflections of someone who is facing her own mortality and has also lost everyone and every place that meant anything to her living through her memories. There are several times that Kath reflects on situations that, despite the sadness or finality, took on a closeness and levity that is only possible in the types of friendships where you can simply have wandering conversations about anything. It is clear that Kath is speaking to a reader who is that kind of friend.
The larger plot is fascinating -- Ishiguro has several things to say about mortality, what we are willing to compromise (ethically) to further ourselves, the difference between faith and curiousity, and what it means to be a person and to be a part of the human condition. That, in and of itself was worth reading, but the book truly shines by being about a sincere depiction of one woman's life and personality within this larger world. You end up caring at least as much about Kath, Ruth and Tommy and their arguments, cassette tapes and classes as the big picture.
It is on the relationship level that Ishiguro shines. The friendships are intricate, completely necessary for the characters and extremely complex. Each character has their own flaws and deals (and doesn't deal) with them in various ways as they come of age.