Geekess reviewed Deadline by Mira Grant
Review of 'Deadline' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
Not as good as the previous book. Shaun isn't as interesting as his sister. Still, McGuire delivers a terrific tale.
Not as good as the previous book. Shaun isn't as interesting as his sister. Still, McGuire delivers a terrific tale.
Deadline is dark and grim and wonderful. A great sequel to Feed, it feels a bit like a heist or a spy thriller, but it is a book of mourning, loss, and deep wells of pain. Welcome to After The End Times: the worst monsters are human.
This book is very hard to discuss without spoiling Feed. To me, the solution is clear. If you have ever liked a zombie book: read this series. If you like political thrillers that get a bit spy/detective as the series moves on: read this series. If you like post-apocalyptic novels: read this series.
I believe the proper response to that ending would be "AaaaaaAaaaaa! ::gasp:: AaaaaaAAaaaaa!!!!!!!" In other words: holy crap that was a good book and I'm glad i have the next on hand to start tomorrow morning
Well, that was unexpected. Nice twist at the end.
I read Deadline in a couple days - a few days faster than Feed. Partially that's because it's holidays and I have a lot of slush time at work and rather than be productive, I'm reading for fun. I'm also slacking off on doing anything in the evenings, making my reading time that much more.
Feed is a better book than Deadline, but I could just like George as the narrator better than Shaun.
I did not see the ending of this book coming.
A ripping yarn. Most of the characters are flat and not all that likeable, and they behave in incomprehensible ways. But a fast read and fun in many ways.
This book really suffered from being a second book. All the fun world-building has already happened, and now the characters more or less just dash about madly getting into place and having revelations so that the climactic showdown of the third book can happen.
I really enjoyed that Sean heard his dead sister's voice, but I kept thinking "Wow, more characters should hear voices, this is a great device!" which is, I am aware, more than a little odd of me.
Also a strange technical choice: half-way through, the reader finally gets the final word on whether Sean and George were actually incestuously involved or just weirdly co-dependent. (It's the former.) And I'm really not sure why it took so long for the author to let me know. It's not like it's a big reveal, it just slips out, and provides a couple more paragraphs of angst for Sean.
Also, …
This book really suffered from being a second book. All the fun world-building has already happened, and now the characters more or less just dash about madly getting into place and having revelations so that the climactic showdown of the third book can happen.
I really enjoyed that Sean heard his dead sister's voice, but I kept thinking "Wow, more characters should hear voices, this is a great device!" which is, I am aware, more than a little odd of me.
Also a strange technical choice: half-way through, the reader finally gets the final word on whether Sean and George were actually incestuously involved or just weirdly co-dependent. (It's the former.) And I'm really not sure why it took so long for the author to let me know. It's not like it's a big reveal, it just slips out, and provides a couple more paragraphs of angst for Sean.
Also, the book doesn't do much end on a cliff-hanger as end ten feet or from the cliff, road-runner style. The editors must agree with me, because the, chapter of the sequel provides at the end at least a couple fingers in the cliffside.
It starts in the same way as Feed, with someone poking a zombie with a stick but soon departs in different direction. If you haven't read Feed yet, then this review will contain spoilers for the first book in the trilogy.
The narration moves to Shaun in this instalment. I think the man we see from his point of view is different from the one George saw and described in Feed. Maybe we can let him off as he's having a tough time getting over the loss of his sister, although she's not completely gone; Shaun has started to hear her voice in his head. He's aware he's most likely crazy but that doesn't stop him trying to get to the bottom of the conspiracy which got her killed.
Whereas Feed dealt with the evolution of news reporting and spread of information, Deadline doesn't have any strong message other than …
It starts in the same way as Feed, with someone poking a zombie with a stick but soon departs in different direction. If you haven't read Feed yet, then this review will contain spoilers for the first book in the trilogy.
The narration moves to Shaun in this instalment. I think the man we see from his point of view is different from the one George saw and described in Feed. Maybe we can let him off as he's having a tough time getting over the loss of his sister, although she's not completely gone; Shaun has started to hear her voice in his head. He's aware he's most likely crazy but that doesn't stop him trying to get to the bottom of the conspiracy which got her killed.
Whereas Feed dealt with the evolution of news reporting and spread of information, Deadline doesn't have any strong message other than the need for answers. There's a lot of repetition, I lost count of the times Shaun explained about his craziness or that he just doesn't care what other people think. The novel is over 500 pages long and it could have easily lost 200 of them and been a better book. Considering they're running round avoiding the CDC and zombies, it all felt a little slow and that wasn't helped by the desire to slap the whining out of Shaun.
And as for those zombies, they didn't really feature much. It was much more about the Kellis-Amberlee virus which in itself is interesting but didn't have a strong enough plot to carry it. There's an event which occurs nearer the end which I would have loved brought forward as it suddenly became gripping and there were all these unanswered questions swirling round in my head. Though I kind of saw the actual ending coming.
Saying all that, I will be reading Blackout when it's released. I like the world that was created in Feed and I want to know what happens next...
I didn't think Mira Grant would manage to make a sequel as gripping and as powerful as [b:Feed|7094569|Feed (Newsflesh, #1)|Mira Grant|http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/516M6ZVVt7L.SL75.jpg|7351419] but, if anything, I found Deadline even more difficult to put down. Mira Grant does not write for people who commute on trains, read on cigarette breaks or want to go to sleep early. She is very good at killing characters I don't expect to die, at times I don't expect them to die and at throwing plot twists I completely didn't see coming.
I can't wait for next year and the close to the trilogy. And I cannot emphasise the word Wow! enough to do this book justice.