Review of 'The Shadow and Bone Trilogy Boxed Set: Shadow and Bone, Siege and Storm, Ruin and Rising' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
3.5
paperback
English language
Published Jan. 18, 2014 by Indigo (an Imprint of Orion Children's), imusti.
Shadow and Bone is a young adult fantasy adventure and debut novel written by Israeli-American author Leigh Bardugo. It was published by Macmillan Publishers on June 5, 2012. The novel is narrated by Alina Starkov, a teenage orphan who grows up in the Russia-inspired land of Ravka when, unexpectedly harnessing a power she never knew she had in order to save her childhood best friend, she becomes a target of intrigue and violence. It is the first book in the Shadow and Bone trilogy, followed by Siege and Storm and Ruin and Rising. It is also the namesake and basis for Netflix adaptation, Shadow and Bone, which premiered in April 2021.
3.5
Alina and Mal are on the run having escaped the devastation wreaked by the Darkling, but the leader of the Grisha Army is never far behind. Alina now carriers the first of Morozova's amplifiers round her neck, and the Darkling wants her power maximised by getting the other two. The search for these amplifiers, whilst trying to avoid the Darkling, is the main driver for the rest of the trilogy.
So the relationships. Honestly, could Mal stop moaning? The love of his live is trying to save the world and not become a slave to a power-hungry Grisha, but he's always thinking about what he wants, how his life doesn't fit with Alina's path, how it's not fair on him. Once Nikolai pops up, Mal also spends a portion of his time being jealous. Mal does redeem himself a bit in the third book but I just didn't feel like …
Alina and Mal are on the run having escaped the devastation wreaked by the Darkling, but the leader of the Grisha Army is never far behind. Alina now carriers the first of Morozova's amplifiers round her neck, and the Darkling wants her power maximised by getting the other two. The search for these amplifiers, whilst trying to avoid the Darkling, is the main driver for the rest of the trilogy.
So the relationships. Honestly, could Mal stop moaning? The love of his live is trying to save the world and not become a slave to a power-hungry Grisha, but he's always thinking about what he wants, how his life doesn't fit with Alina's path, how it's not fair on him. Once Nikolai pops up, Mal also spends a portion of his time being jealous. Mal does redeem himself a bit in the third book but I just didn't feel like there was much for Alina to lose in Siege and Storm if he were to flounce off.
I really liked Nikolai though, he's humourous but also good without being too shiny perfect. He likes to think that he's perfect though! For a land so plagued by tragedy, it is so hopeful in a story to have a potential leader who would be good. It also meant that the thing that happens to him in Ruin and Rising had my heart in my throat. He elicited the feelings that I felt I should have had for Mal.
I just finished my reread of this trilogy (July 2019) and I loooved it.
I didnt re-read books bc I thought it was a loss of time to read something where you already knew the events, the end (stupid, how can I remember everything about books I read years ago lol). But it turns out I had a lot of fun reading this physically and annotating my book (I annotate waaaay too much), and wow, I can't wait for the King of Scars sequel^^
*Im shaking my head at myself bc I wanted to slowly read the Grishaverse books to build anticipation for the KoS sequel but welp that escalated quickly..
SPOILERS
I love the little gang in R&R they are everything, I giggled so much, and Zoya was a delight in her scenes (I loved noticing the references to King of Scars), as was Nikolaï ofc and Genya, Tamar, …
I just finished my reread of this trilogy (July 2019) and I loooved it.
I didnt re-read books bc I thought it was a loss of time to read something where you already knew the events, the end (stupid, how can I remember everything about books I read years ago lol). But it turns out I had a lot of fun reading this physically and annotating my book (I annotate waaaay too much), and wow, I can't wait for the King of Scars sequel^^
*Im shaking my head at myself bc I wanted to slowly read the Grishaverse books to build anticipation for the KoS sequel but welp that escalated quickly..
SPOILERS
I love the little gang in R&R they are everything, I giggled so much, and Zoya was a delight in her scenes (I loved noticing the references to King of Scars), as was Nikolaï ofc and Genya, Tamar, Tolya.. Anywayyyy Alina my Sun Summoner (so sad when she lost her powers..), my Queen, I hope to see her in the KoS sequel (really need the title for reasons).
That's right, after finishing Shadow and Bone im rereading this!! Lets gooo
Reread July 2019 : still easy to read and I enjoyed it BUT I would rate it 4 stars now.. (Nikolai is my ray of sunshine)
Ok im re-reading this book (and hopefully all of the books in the Grishaverse) in preparation for the next release in the King of Scars duology^^
Welll I loved it, not bad for a 1st re-read, I was in a bit of a slump but I read this one so quickly
2019 re-read : 4.5/5
This was an impulse buy for me. I wasn't sure if I was going to like it or not, especially when I started stumbling over all the Russian or Russian-inspired names and words. However, it turned out to be a surprisingly easy and quick read and I enjoyed it.
Alina and her best friend Mal are orphaned at an early age by the Border Wars. Peasants, they are sent to be raised on a duke's estate, where they will be educated and taught a trade. When their training is finished, they join the army - Alina as a mapmaker and Mal as a scout. The two are still best friends and are inseparable, though Alina's feelings are definitely no longer platonic. Alina's life is pretty normal - until the fateful day her troop enters the notorious Shadow Fold.
I don't really know how to describe the Fold except to quote …
This was an impulse buy for me. I wasn't sure if I was going to like it or not, especially when I started stumbling over all the Russian or Russian-inspired names and words. However, it turned out to be a surprisingly easy and quick read and I enjoyed it.
Alina and her best friend Mal are orphaned at an early age by the Border Wars. Peasants, they are sent to be raised on a duke's estate, where they will be educated and taught a trade. When their training is finished, they join the army - Alina as a mapmaker and Mal as a scout. The two are still best friends and are inseparable, though Alina's feelings are definitely no longer platonic. Alina's life is pretty normal - until the fateful day her troop enters the notorious Shadow Fold.
I don't really know how to describe the Fold except to quote Alina: "At first, it was like drifting into a thick cloud of smoke, but there was no heat, no smell of fire. Sounds seemed to dampen and the world became still...The living world had disappeared. Darkness fell around us, black, weightless, and absolute. We were in the Fold." They are not the only ones in the Fold - so are deadly monsters called volcra, which travel in flocks and attack Alina and her companions. It is during this attack that Mal is injured and Alina attacks - and everything changes permanently for her. Alina's hidden power is awakened by the shock of the attack and she is knocked unconscious.
When Alina awakens, she is taken to see the powerful - even infamous - Darkling, the most powerful Grisha (mage or spellcaster) in the land. He examines Alina and she is found to be a Grisha as well. Alina is forced to leave the army, Mal (who is recovering), and everything else she knows, and go to the Little Palace, where she will be trained to use her powers. It becomes soon apparent that the Darkling has a special interest in Alina, though she is not sure if it is personal or if it's due to her powers. Alina is no ordinary Grisha - she is a Sun Summoner, a very powerful Grisha who may be able to destroy the Shadow Fold once and for all. Unless, of course, someone else has a better use for her powers - or wants her dead before she can master them.
I definitely plan to buy "Siege and Storm," which is the second volume. I liked Alina and enjoyed her story. It's also nice to see something other than the same old Western European/Sword & Sorcery stuff. This is the first fantasy world I can remember with a Russian theme. It's very refreshing.
Alina is an orphan, under the care of Duke Keramsov, when the Grisha first come to test her and her only friend, Mal. Neither of them show any signs of the small science that make the Grisha so powerful so they are left alone, to join a life in the King's army. The once-great nation of Ravka is battling the Shadow Fold, a barren land bereft of light. Within the darkness are creatures that will rip you apart, the volcra. When their regiment has to pass through the Shadow Fold, Mal is attacked and Alina throws herself in the path of a volcra. Only something amazing happens. Could Alina have powers of the Grisha, dormant for so many years? And is she the key to saving Ravka from the darkness?
As someone who doesn't read a lot of high fantasy (that's the stuff set in other worlds), I often have …
Alina is an orphan, under the care of Duke Keramsov, when the Grisha first come to test her and her only friend, Mal. Neither of them show any signs of the small science that make the Grisha so powerful so they are left alone, to join a life in the King's army. The once-great nation of Ravka is battling the Shadow Fold, a barren land bereft of light. Within the darkness are creatures that will rip you apart, the volcra. When their regiment has to pass through the Shadow Fold, Mal is attacked and Alina throws herself in the path of a volcra. Only something amazing happens. Could Alina have powers of the Grisha, dormant for so many years? And is she the key to saving Ravka from the darkness?
As someone who doesn't read a lot of high fantasy (that's the stuff set in other worlds), I often have difficulty getting to grips with a new world, especially all the made up words. I felt this way for the first few chapters of The Gathering Dark but soon started to get into the world of the Grisha. They don't think of it as magic however, more science but there wasn't enough to back this up. I would have liked to have seen more on this, but as it's the first in a trilogy, there is likely to be more on its way.
There are three types of Grisha; the Corporalki who have power over blood, the Etherealki who have power over the elements and the Materialki who have power over solid things such as metal. They all in turn, are lead by the Darkling who has power over darkness and is both feared and respected. The peasants think the Grisha are witches yet they form the second army, using their powers to back up the first army of the King.
The plot, at first, seems to be rather cliched. Orphan girl suddenly finds she's has magical powers and goes to live in a wonderful palace yet doesn't quite fit in. Yet somewhere along the way, it evolves and becomes a gripping fantasy adventure. There's even a villain that keeps you wanting to see the good in him. I still have hope, although I think younger readers will see it more in black and white.
My criticism is that it skims the surface of too many things. The mythology of the Grisha, the world within the Shadow Fold, the relationships. There's a lot going on but feels like it's been edited down to fit into a length acceptable for the young adult market. I would certainly read the second instalment, The Shadow Fold when it's available, as my curiosity has been piqued.