This is a whodunnit book written for idiots. Every plot point is repeated carefully so you’re not going to miss anything; every part of the slightly torturous plot is carefully explained in cutaway “he remembered when she said…” devices. It’s an unsophisticated book, without any real character development, and every vaguely difficult plot point spelled out in a tediously obvious way. And it’ll sell very well because it’s Dan Brown - just like high fructose snacks sell very well because they’re super sweet and made to be easy to eat. Except they leave you feeling rather unsatisfied too.
User Profile
My home in Bookwyrm. Not my home on the fediverse. That's @james@bne.social
This link opens in a pop-up window
James Cridland's reading's books
To Read (View all 27)
User Activity
RSS feed Back
James Cridland's reading reviewed Secret of Secrets by Dan Brown (Robert Langdon, #6)
James Cridland's reading finished reading Secret of Secrets by Dan Brown (Robert Langdon, #6)
This is a whodunnit book written for idiots. Every plot point is repeated carefully so you’re not going to miss anything; every part of the slightly torturous plot is carefully explained in cutaway “he remembered when she said…” devices. It’s an unsophisticated book, without any real character development, and every vaguely difficult plot point spelled out in a tediously obvious way. And it’ll sell very well because it’s Dan Brown - just like high fructose snacks sell very well because they’re super sweet and made to be easy to eat.
James Cridland's reading reviewed The Siege by Ben Macintyre
Fascinating read
5 stars
I wasn't old enough to really remember the siege itself; so I had the benefit of not really knowing how it would end. That certainly added to the excitement of the book, which is written very well and is clearly researched in a very focused way. An impressive read, and very enjoyable.
I wasn't old enough to really remember the siege itself; so I had the benefit of not really knowing how it would end. That certainly added to the excitement of the book, which is written very well and is clearly researched in a very focused way. An impressive read, and very enjoyable.
The Plague (French: La Peste) is a novel by Albert Camus, published in 1947, that …
Review of '[1948 Modern Library Edition] The Plague by Albert Camus; Translated from the French by Stuart Gilbert' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
Just finished this. Quite hard work, and obviously now we've all lived through COVID, it's less "amazing thing that will never happen" and more "a bit like 2020". I'm glad I ploughed through it, but I didn't really gel with any of the characters, and the storytelling device was a bit strange.
Just finished this. Quite hard work, and obviously now we've all lived through COVID, it's less "amazing thing that will never happen" and more "a bit like 2020". I'm glad I ploughed through it, but I didn't really gel with any of the characters, and the storytelling device was a bit strange.
Review of 'Underground' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
This was rather a good read: not particularly a "history" (and that would be too dry, anyway) but instead a number of stories of discovering caves, subway tunnels, catacombs and more: all with an underlying spiritual message like a rather insistent, repetitive drum, about our relationship to the great unseen underground.
It's compared with a Bill Bryson academic book on the cover; that's as wide of the mark as the subtitle of being a history book. But the Bill Bryson comparison would perhaps work better if it's compared with one of his travel books where he visits new and unknown places; except in this book, all the places are underground.
It certainly makes you think - and as a relatively recent immigrant to Australia, it's fascinating to read a whole chapter on the relationships that our traditional owners have with caves and underground areas.
This was rather a good read: not particularly a "history" (and that would be too dry, anyway) but instead a number of stories of discovering caves, subway tunnels, catacombs and more: all with an underlying spiritual message like a rather insistent, repetitive drum, about our relationship to the great unseen underground.
It's compared with a Bill Bryson academic book on the cover; that's as wide of the mark as the subtitle of being a history book. But the Bill Bryson comparison would perhaps work better if it's compared with one of his travel books where he visits new and unknown places; except in this book, all the places are underground.
It certainly makes you think - and as a relatively recent immigrant to Australia, it's fascinating to read a whole chapter on the relationships that our traditional owners have with caves and underground areas.
James Cridland's reading reviewed The Blair years by Alastair Campbell (Borzoi book)
Review of 'The Blair years' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
A fascinating read - I grew up during the Blair government, and these diaries show that it wasn't quite as well organised as it seemed. Particularly, the part of the media to destabilise a government appears to be quite well displayed here. As the world moves on, I'm quite impressed with Campbell - self-validating though this might be, there are some fascinating parts of this for anyone seeking to understand the world as it was back then.
A fascinating read - I grew up during the Blair government, and these diaries show that it wasn't quite as well organised as it seemed. Particularly, the part of the media to destabilise a government appears to be quite well displayed here. As the world moves on, I'm quite impressed with Campbell - self-validating though this might be, there are some fascinating parts of this for anyone seeking to understand the world as it was back then.
Review of 'Nothing to Envy: Ordinary Lives in North Korea' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
I've read a fair amount of books about North Korea, but this one is by far the most powerful and detailed book about normal life in the country. It's a very detailed and impressive book, following a number of ordinary North Koreans, and doesn't hold back on the positivity of the regime there as well as its faults and concerns. Most certainly the most interesting book I've read, and done in such a matter-of-fact, non-exaggerated way, it's hard to accuse it of being propaganda: indeed, the fact checking appears to be very well done. A difficult book in places, but worthwhile reading.
I've read a fair amount of books about North Korea, but this one is by far the most powerful and detailed book about normal life in the country. It's a very detailed and impressive book, following a number of ordinary North Koreans, and doesn't hold back on the positivity of the regime there as well as its faults and concerns. Most certainly the most interesting book I've read, and done in such a matter-of-fact, non-exaggerated way, it's hard to accuse it of being propaganda: indeed, the fact checking appears to be very well done. A difficult book in places, but worthwhile reading.
James Cridland's reading reviewed Vaxxers by Sarah Gilbert
Review of 'Vaxxers' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
A good and enlightening read. I've had the Oxford AstraZeneca vaccine, and this book explains much of the press coverage, and even allays some fears about speed. It's very much worth a read: I managed to get through it in a day or so, though I'll freely admit a little of it was a little over my head.
Worth a read for the vaccine-hesitant, or at the minimum, those who want to learn more about what they've put in their arm.
A good and enlightening read. I've had the Oxford AstraZeneca vaccine, and this book explains much of the press coverage, and even allays some fears about speed. It's very much worth a read: I managed to get through it in a day or so, though I'll freely admit a little of it was a little over my head.
Worth a read for the vaccine-hesitant, or at the minimum, those who want to learn more about what they've put in their arm.
James Cridland's reading reviewed In Cold Blood by Truman Capote
Review of 'In Cold Blood' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
There's a reason you've probably heard of this book even if you haven't read it, and the fact that it has, at the time of writing, 580,000 ratings on GoodReads probably underlines it - it's a classic, apparently. But, like a classic car, there are some bits that don't work too well - with some overly florid language, particularly at the beginning of the book, almost signalling that Capote is trying too hard.
Occasionally, you get the feeling that he's being paid by the word. Perhaps he was: long excerpts from letters and documents pop up every so often that do little to aid the story or to develop character.
The pacing of the story is a little odd, too, with some parts whisking by, and other parts dwelled on with glacial slowness. But then, I'm not a literature teacher, and if I were, I'd probably point out why he's …
There's a reason you've probably heard of this book even if you haven't read it, and the fact that it has, at the time of writing, 580,000 ratings on GoodReads probably underlines it - it's a classic, apparently. But, like a classic car, there are some bits that don't work too well - with some overly florid language, particularly at the beginning of the book, almost signalling that Capote is trying too hard.
Occasionally, you get the feeling that he's being paid by the word. Perhaps he was: long excerpts from letters and documents pop up every so often that do little to aid the story or to develop character.
The pacing of the story is a little odd, too, with some parts whisking by, and other parts dwelled on with glacial slowness. But then, I'm not a literature teacher, and if I were, I'd probably point out why he's doing it. But I'm not, so I don't know why.
I later discover, after reading, that it first appeared in the New Yorker as a serial, published over four editions. That might explain some of the above - a requirement to reach a natural break-point for publication, perhaps.
In any case - it's fine, it's a good read, it's told well and with flair, if slightly too much flair in some cases. It's a good true crime thriller, in the same way as others which have followed. But personally I don't think it's worth full marks here - enjoyable though it was.
James Cridland's reading reviewed The Rum Diary by Hunter S. Thompson
Review of 'The Rum Diary ' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
I do wonder, with books like these, how the main subject ever gets anything done, given that he appears blind drunk all the time. Sometimes light and funny, sometimes rather more dark, I gather this is early Hunter S Thompson, and therefore before he discovers acid. It was OK; the plot line mostly as-to-be-expected from the first few chapters, and the characters varied and interesting. Not sure I'd put it in a list of favourites, though.
I do wonder, with books like these, how the main subject ever gets anything done, given that he appears blind drunk all the time. Sometimes light and funny, sometimes rather more dark, I gather this is early Hunter S Thompson, and therefore before he discovers acid. It was OK; the plot line mostly as-to-be-expected from the first few chapters, and the characters varied and interesting. Not sure I'd put it in a list of favourites, though.
James Cridland's reading reviewed Brave New World by Aldous Huxley
Review of 'Brave New World' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
Everyone's supposed to have read this book already, but I hadn't. I knew very little about it, other than I'd written it down on a list to read after someone mentioned it in a throwaway comment - "you know, like Brave New World".
The obvious comparison is to George Orwell's 1984, though Huxley is much darker. Orwell brings lots of interesting detail in terms of his vision of the future; Huxley's future is less focused: we learn about recreation, but very little about living quarters, or food, or much else. A television is mentioned at one point; but at one moment of action, someone scrabbles to look up a telephone number, an action that seems quaint and old-fashioned.
Like Orwell, Huxley makes you think. His vision is just as sinister, but both more joyous and more controlling. It's an interesting thought: and I wonder whether all our politicians have read …
Everyone's supposed to have read this book already, but I hadn't. I knew very little about it, other than I'd written it down on a list to read after someone mentioned it in a throwaway comment - "you know, like Brave New World".
The obvious comparison is to George Orwell's 1984, though Huxley is much darker. Orwell brings lots of interesting detail in terms of his vision of the future; Huxley's future is less focused: we learn about recreation, but very little about living quarters, or food, or much else. A television is mentioned at one point; but at one moment of action, someone scrabbles to look up a telephone number, an action that seems quaint and old-fashioned.
Like Orwell, Huxley makes you think. His vision is just as sinister, but both more joyous and more controlling. It's an interesting thought: and I wonder whether all our politicians have read this book and have honed policies around it. Stranger things have happened...
James Cridland's reading reviewed Landslide by Michael Wolff
Review of 'Landslide' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
I read the first of this trilogy, and found it quite depressing. This, with the benefit of knowing that Trump isn't in office any more, is a much easier read, and is actually quite funny in places. We learn that Rudy Giuliani is an often-drunk guy with a very farty bottom. The story of Election Night is fascinating, as is the refusal of Trump to believe he's lost. At the end of the book, Trump appears like a sad old nutter - living in Mar-A-Lago like it's some kind of old folks home, talking to literally anyone who'll listen to him. I doubt it would be anywhere near as funny if he were still in office, but he isn't, and so it's a good read. And Rudy Giuliani's farts are an excellent recurring feature, as they appear to be in real life.
I read the first of this trilogy, and found it quite depressing. This, with the benefit of knowing that Trump isn't in office any more, is a much easier read, and is actually quite funny in places. We learn that Rudy Giuliani is an often-drunk guy with a very farty bottom. The story of Election Night is fascinating, as is the refusal of Trump to believe he's lost. At the end of the book, Trump appears like a sad old nutter - living in Mar-A-Lago like it's some kind of old folks home, talking to literally anyone who'll listen to him. I doubt it would be anywhere near as funny if he were still in office, but he isn't, and so it's a good read. And Rudy Giuliani's farts are an excellent recurring feature, as they appear to be in real life.
James Cridland's reading reviewed Catch and Kill by Ronan Farrow
Review of 'Catch and Kill' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
A very excellent book. I didn't know who Ronan Farrow was, and read the first quarter of the book thinking that she was a woman. It turns out he isn't. Spoiler.
Anyway, this is a fascinating book. I was expecting it to be a difficult read, but it was much less about the crimes of Weinstein and much more about the reporting of them, and the attempts to silence him.
This is a great piece of journalism, and deservedly won accolades. You wonder how much of the story was able to be reported because if who Farrow was, rather than his journalistic skills - but he seems quite open about that, as well as the difficulties he had in getting the story out there.
A very good read, and recommended.
A very excellent book. I didn't know who Ronan Farrow was, and read the first quarter of the book thinking that she was a woman. It turns out he isn't. Spoiler.
Anyway, this is a fascinating book. I was expecting it to be a difficult read, but it was much less about the crimes of Weinstein and much more about the reporting of them, and the attempts to silence him.
This is a great piece of journalism, and deservedly won accolades. You wonder how much of the story was able to be reported because if who Farrow was, rather than his journalistic skills - but he seems quite open about that, as well as the difficulties he had in getting the story out there.
A very good read, and recommended.
James Cridland's reading reviewed Silly Isles by Eric Campbell
Review of 'Silly Isles' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
This was a good read: a little easier than Absurdistan, and a little more kind of normal. You get the feeling that this is a job for him, and it's not that odd a job to go off and learn about funny little places across the world. He writes well and it's an interesting read about places that I've, by and large, only read about. Less of a "story", and more of a collection of short essays, but none the worse for that.
This was a good read: a little easier than Absurdistan, and a little more kind of normal. You get the feeling that this is a job for him, and it's not that odd a job to go off and learn about funny little places across the world. He writes well and it's an interesting read about places that I've, by and large, only read about. Less of a "story", and more of a collection of short essays, but none the worse for that.












