ridel reviewed Lost fleet: Dauntless by Jack Campbell (The lost fleet, #1)
Review of 'Lost fleet' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
Dauntless is an excellent novel to start off a military sci-fi series and setting, but it does start on extremely rocky footing and ends extremely quickly, leaving you wanting more. Jack Campbell's real life experience with in a navy means that he has an excellent grasp of military organizations, and this is translated extraordinarily well into text so that even us laymen can see the authenticity.
While the novel sells you on the idea of a man out of time, turned into a hero posthumously, struggling to live up to those ideals, I actually found the novel to be a brilliant breakdown on what might happen to society if it actually fought a modern 'total' war for a hundred years. Jack Campbell has given a great deal of thought to the military organization and its changes, and if there are oddities, I beg that you give the author time and …
Dauntless is an excellent novel to start off a military sci-fi series and setting, but it does start on extremely rocky footing and ends extremely quickly, leaving you wanting more. Jack Campbell's real life experience with in a navy means that he has an excellent grasp of military organizations, and this is translated extraordinarily well into text so that even us laymen can see the authenticity.
While the novel sells you on the idea of a man out of time, turned into a hero posthumously, struggling to live up to those ideals, I actually found the novel to be a brilliant breakdown on what might happen to society if it actually fought a modern 'total' war for a hundred years. Jack Campbell has given a great deal of thought to the military organization and its changes, and if there are oddities, I beg that you give the author time and space to make it clear why these things happened. His real-life experiences ensure that almost any part of the Alliance Navy that seems 'wrong' has very good reasons.
That said, the novel starts off with a poorly written cold-open which may alienate a lot of readers. The villains are either under-characterized or one-dimensional feckless assholes. Additionally, the novel is very short and you'll be left wanting more. I started Fearless (the next novel) immediately and while this is a fun, enjoyable ride, I don't see it being complex/thrilling enough for it to be perfect.
Recommended with reservations.