I Finally Figured Out How to Give Half Stars!!!
4 stars
This is a real-McCoy when it comes to high fantasy: extremely complex, long, descriptive, sometimes a little gratuitous with the violence, sexism, ableism, and the series' overall cynical opinion of humanity. In spite of its flaws and many valid criticisms, I think its success is still deserved for the care that went into not only the worldbuilding but especially each and every character who really feels like their own flesh-and-blood person with flaws and contradictions and vulnerabilities. ASoIaF really took the high-fantasy genre seriously while we were bombarded with too much irony and satire and made its most ambitious iteration yet in a way that Tolkein would've been proud, not to mention kick starting the Noun of Noun and Noun template for fantasy titles. Here's to hoping Martin finishes that gd manuscript before he's pushing daisies.
PS Actually another flaw I'd like to point out is that over time, the âŠ
This is a real-McCoy when it comes to high fantasy: extremely complex, long, descriptive, sometimes a little gratuitous with the violence, sexism, ableism, and the series' overall cynical opinion of humanity. In spite of its flaws and many valid criticisms, I think its success is still deserved for the care that went into not only the worldbuilding but especially each and every character who really feels like their own flesh-and-blood person with flaws and contradictions and vulnerabilities. ASoIaF really took the high-fantasy genre seriously while we were bombarded with too much irony and satire and made its most ambitious iteration yet in a way that Tolkein would've been proud, not to mention kick starting the Noun of Noun and Noun template for fantasy titles. Here's to hoping Martin finishes that gd manuscript before he's pushing daisies.
PS Actually another flaw I'd like to point out is that over time, the books begin to focus more and more on previously minor characters, adding more points-of-view with every book and not every character is as interesting as the last. Most people agree that Arya and Tyrion are the most interesting characters and yet they hardly show up by the second half of book five and we're stuck with Reek. A natural consequence of ambition, I guess.