Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries

Emily Wilde is a scholar from a 19th century Cambridge (UK), but in a world where the Fae are elusive but very much accepted as real. While continuing her work to complete the Encyclopedia of Fairies of the title, she travels to investigate the Fae of Scandinavia, and we follow her tale through her journal entries. What’s clever is a unusual and sensitive portray of Emily, who we see finally able to overcome some social ineptitude and start a slow-burning romance with her dashing academic rival and Cambridge colleague, Wendell, who of course has a mysterious background. My favourite parts were the Fae stories themselves (including the interludes outside the plot - literal stories within the story presented as journal footnotes); there’s nothing particularly new there, everything is very traditional folklore - it’s just very well done. What does jar is that the author clearly has no idea of Cambridge academia (tenure is a concept that is neither Cambridge nor period), although we don’t spend too much time in that setting for it to be the problem it could be. For an expert on the Fae, Emily does also find herself trapped and take odd actions just a little too easily. A lighter read, but with some memorable darkness and some humour, but not enough for me to instantly want to buy the sequel.

(This is my original review from Goodreads, I read it in January and reread it this December. Easily a book I'm going to continue returning to yearly.)

I went into this book highly skeptical of it being able to pull off the combination of academics and fantasy, but it is now easily one of my favorite books in its genre.

The characters each have their own voices and distinct characterizations; from gruff but kindhearted townsfolk, to the "mousy" but dedicated main character, to, of course, the flamboyant but loving love interest, who I found was delightful to read.

The world is as fun to read about as the characters. Fawcett has a beautiful way of narrating that makes everything feel fresh and interesting, which only makes it more powerful when the characters come upon anything magical in their environment.

The book isn't perfect. In some spots the story felt a little thin, like there wasn't really anything connecting a couple of the events to the main storyline. But that just meant that we got to meet more characters and find greater depth in characters we already knew, so I don't really have any complaints about that. The events were still engaging, but didn't always fit in perfectly with the main plot is all I'm saying.

5/5 for making me want to immediately devour the next book, for having the cutest love story I've ever read, and having me laying in bed giggling and kicking my feet while reading the bickering between the main characters. I recommend this book to anyone who is interested in a scientific approach to the fae, a fun frenemies to lovers story, and a plot that will have you loving every character for each of their quirks.

One doesn’t need magic if one knows enough stories.

I think I expected more from this book, but I did enjoy what I got. There's such a strong sense of setting here, and it's precisely the kind of setting I love: a tiny community on the snow-covered edge of the world, surrounded by forests and mountains and frozen lakes, all of it touched with fairy magic. I enjoyed the way the fairy lore was handled: the academic approach to it, the relationship between the fairy magic/tradition and story tropes, and how close the fairies here are to what I expect from them based on folklore: fickle and cold-hearted and dangerously beautiful. The second half of the book was particularly strong in terms of this.

I also very much liked the mixture of cozy fantasy and fairy folk horror, or at least the concept of it. In practice, the coziness part kind of kept falling short for me, probably because of the amount of friction between Emily and the villagers at the beginning. Sure, it wasn't unreasonable of them to expect her to learn a bit about their customs and traditions before coming to stay. At the same time, it also wasn't unreasonable to assume that maybe those customs are, you know, foreign for her, so why not spell everything out before taking offense without explaining the faux pas? Communication is good! Also, Emily is very clearly portrayed as neudorivergent and struggles with societal expectations even in a familiar setting. That is something I very much relate to and sympathize with, so it hurt to see her given the cold shoulder for not living up to a standard outside of her scope. Which is why, even once the bridges were mended, it was difficult for me to truly get into the cozy parts. I kind of kept a grudge. :D And then there's also the fact that I somehow expect cozy fantasy books to have kind characters, and Emily is smart and interesting and complex, but I wouldn't call her particularly kind.

From the summary and some of the reviews I've seen, I expected the romantic storyline to be more prominent. As it was, it wasn't exactly subtle and it's certainly present at the forefront of the story most of the time. Emily and Wendell have a lot of fun moments together; taken in isolation, they're great exampls of the kind of grumpy x sunshine dynamic I tend to enjoy in fiction. But I just can't see them moving from that into an actual relationship for some reason. Which, much like my definition of cozy fiction, is largely a personal taste/preference thing, of course.

What objectively made it a bit difficult to maintain immersion was the journal entries format. On one hand, I get why the author chose it for this story over a regular first person narration. It fits the story itself, and it also allowed for that one very fun chapter around the middle—you know which one, if you've read the book. On the other hand, the amount of dialogue and the abundance of moment that felt just like regular first person narration... well, like I said, immersion got tricky. The idea behind the format is good, but the execution could use more polish, I suppose.

4.5 stars.

This first book in the adult series "Emily Wilde" was not perfect, but it's the first time I have read a book like this one, making it difficult for me to rate it. I see all the aspects which need some improvement and I see why this book doesn't work for several people. Nonetheless, I have enjoyed much more than I expected because I could relate to Emily. I will start listing the cons and then come back to the reasons why it is still worked out for me.

Most of the issues are just the consequences of the diary format. Emily brings with her a fieldwork notebook and we see her entries over a time of 6 months. This means that we have only Emily's point of view (besides for a couple of entries by Wendell), leaving the characterization of othe characters very limited. On the other hand, I noticed the efforts and the very well crafted writing to create depth.
Also, Emily feels very real and human with her imperfections and weaknesses. I could follow her reasoning and motivations.

The plot is, in my opinion, the weakest aspect of this book. The pace was very slow for the first two thirds and little happened, while the finale feels very rushed. I didn't mind though, because it mirrored the fact that Emily was getting adjusted to a new place, people, routine, etc. It also had this kinda of "cozy" feeling or "slice-of-life" vibe, which I enjoyed it. I would have appreciated some pages more to give more space to the conclusion. Also, where did the students end up? At the beginning it is mentioned that they were gone, but nobody cared about them.

To sum it up, I enjoyed the vibes and could connect with Emily in a way that rarely happens. Probably it's because I love dogs and I am doing my PhD, but I also shared Emily's curiosity. That made me stand the negative aspects much easier. If you are into a comfortable winter read with a nice protagonist and story, I would recommend you reading it.