Reviews and Comments

P. E. T. Conroy

petconroy@bookwyrm.social

Joined 2 years, 1 month ago

Perpetual University Student Startup Novelist Lapsed Podcaster Academic Theologian, Historian and Communications LinkTr.ee/PETConroy

This link opens in a pop-up window

Thomas Olde Heuvelt: Echo (2022, Doherty Associates, LLC, Tom) 4 stars

A delightfully painful read: TOH is Stephen King for this generation.

5 stars

I recently read Children of Húrin. A challenging read. Last year I read @Olde_Heuvelt's HEX, that was a difficult read. This, is a painful read, a page-turning fight with every word. You feel every rock & slip on that mountain. WOW. TOH is Stephen King for this generation. ❤️&💔

reviewed Malarkoi by Alex Pheby (Cities of the Weft, #2)

Alex Pheby: Malarkoi (2022, Galley Beggar Press) 4 stars

Nathan Treeves is dead, murdered by the Master of Mordew, his remains used to create …

Looking forward to the sequel (but this was a slog)

4 stars

This book feels longer - there is a lot of preamble before the story starts, which is the author catching you up to where everyone is geographically and figuratively - and although well written, the book is still bloated with pomposity in its language and over-philosophizing, and this detracts from what is an enjoyable story now cut short (this is the second in the trilogy, and you still can't trust anyone but the dogs it seems)...

For these reasons, this book is a struggle to love and gets three stars.

reviewed Mordew by Alex Pheby (Cities of the Weft, #1)

Alex Pheby: Mordew (Hardcover, 2021, Tor Books) 4 stars

GOD IS DEAD, his corpse hidden in the catacombs beneath Mordew.

In the slums of …

Looking forward to the sequel

5 stars

Content warning May contain hints of some plot points/elements

Angélica Gorodischer, Angélica Gorodischer: Kalpa imperial (2003, Small Beer Press) 4 stars

«Oh, sí, mis buenas gentes, sí, ya lo creo que sí. Se puede vivir en …

Short stories of a fictional empire and the oral storyteller that connects them

5 stars

A collection of connected short stories set in a fictional [possibly post-apocolyptic] empire about its many rulers and cities and across many years. The stories are short and leave you wanting to know more about the people in them.

The writing is tight with just enough description to convince you they're being told by an oral storyteller, but it's not flowery and at times you wish you could hear a little bit more description.

However, one failing is how the stories connect. Other than the oral storyteller and the empire they pertain to, one is left wondering what connects them together. What are the relationships between all the emperors and empresses? Unfortunately, I suspect that would require a fictional history lesson and a long kings list, which would most certainly distract from the stories themselves.

stopped reading Kalpa imperial by Angélica Gorodischer

Angélica Gorodischer, Angélica Gorodischer: Kalpa imperial (2003, Small Beer Press) 4 stars

«Oh, sí, mis buenas gentes, sí, ya lo creo que sí. Se puede vivir en …

A collection of connected short stories set in a fictional [possibly post-apocolyptic] empire about its many rulers and cities and across many years. The stories are short and leave you wanting to know more about the people in them.

The writing is tight with just enough description to convince you they're being told by an oral storyteller, but it's not flowery and at times you wish you could hear a little bit more description.

However, one failing is how the stories connect. Other than the oral storyteller and the empire they pertain to one is left wondering what connects them together. What are the relationships between all the emperors and impresses? Unfortunately, I suspect that would require a fictional history lesson and a long kings list, which would most certainly distract from the stories themselves.