A Natural History of Dragons
3 stars
3 stars: enjoyed this book, you might like it too
Copying over from goodreads
Fun but not particularly memorable
3 stars: enjoyed this book, you might like it too
Copying over from goodreads
Fun but not particularly memorable
An interesting start to the series. Written in the form of a memoir when she is much older, this book tells the story of Isabella, who becomes fascinated by dragons from childhood and grows up wanting to learn more about them. But she is constricted by the Victorian-like society that she grows up in that expect women to 'know their place' in society and not to stick out by doing unladylike things like being fascinated by dragons.
Then chance intervenes, and she gets the opportunity to go on an expedition to study wild dragons in a far country. But things don't start out well; their guide is missing and dragons are attacking the village. And in the process of their investigations about dragons, Isabella stumbles on to a secret that may well affect her natural study of dragons: for if the secret becomes well known, it may mean the end …
An interesting start to the series. Written in the form of a memoir when she is much older, this book tells the story of Isabella, who becomes fascinated by dragons from childhood and grows up wanting to learn more about them. But she is constricted by the Victorian-like society that she grows up in that expect women to 'know their place' in society and not to stick out by doing unladylike things like being fascinated by dragons.
Then chance intervenes, and she gets the opportunity to go on an expedition to study wild dragons in a far country. But things don't start out well; their guide is missing and dragons are attacking the village. And in the process of their investigations about dragons, Isabella stumbles on to a secret that may well affect her natural study of dragons: for if the secret becomes well known, it may mean the end of dragons.
Most stories about dragons tend to focus on the fantasy part of dragons; this series attracted me because it hints that it would try to treat dragons as real life animals and attempt to portray them realistically. This first book concentrates more on the growing up of Isabella than of dragons, which only makes a brief appearance in the book. But it does provide some hints about the natural history of dragons, why they are worth studying, and what Isabella would have to do if she is to try to protect the secret about the dragons for now.
On to the next one in the series to see what other natural revelations about dragons will be revealed.
I love it. I love the mock-memoir writing style, I love the art, I love the characters. The books are so pretty I actually bought them as hardcover editions right after I finished this ebook version.
The writing was fun and charming, the protagonist (head-)strong and smart. I got a bit confused by all the supposedly-different-but-clearly-modelled-after-European-states countries. Apart from that I can't wait for the second part of Lady Trent's memoir.
I picked this up because the "Memoirs of Lady Trent" series is nominated for a Hugo this year. I thoroughly enjoyed the first book, and will continue reading the series. It's a bit like Elizabeth Peter's "Amelia Peabody" series. The protagonist, Isabella, is an unconventional young woman with a passionate interest in an intellectual subject, only it's dragons instead of the history of Egypt.
The world strongly resembles the Victorian era, with minor name changes to allow for dragons. Isabella is delightful, and Brennan navigates the difficult waters of Victorian attitudes about different classes pretty adroitly.
Pretty darn nifty, and much more composed than I'd expected.
Well, it was okay. I had some trouble getting into it, and then part of the ending became rather predictable once specific characters were introduced. Other parts of the ending were never really resolved at all. It wasn't until the halfway point that I actually started feeling invested in it. Some of this probably due to geography issues. I listened to an audiobook and as such I get nothing in the way of maps, so all these made up countries and places and how they relate to each other means little to nothing. Plus when you hear them read out but never see them in writing, it takes a very long time for it to start sounding like a place and not just 'something made up'. (Especially, when some of them sound a bit sort of 'made up via keyboard mashing', but that might simply be due to the format …
Well, it was okay. I had some trouble getting into it, and then part of the ending became rather predictable once specific characters were introduced. Other parts of the ending were never really resolved at all. It wasn't until the halfway point that I actually started feeling invested in it. Some of this probably due to geography issues. I listened to an audiobook and as such I get nothing in the way of maps, so all these made up countries and places and how they relate to each other means little to nothing. Plus when you hear them read out but never see them in writing, it takes a very long time for it to start sounding like a place and not just 'something made up'. (Especially, when some of them sound a bit sort of 'made up via keyboard mashing', but that might simply be due to the format that I had)
I've got the two next ones on audio as well, but haven't yet decided whether or not I liked it enough to continue with them. I'll have to let it ferment for a little while and see if I feel curious.
This was an interesting first book on the life and adventures of Isabella as she sets out to learn about dragons. I found the memoir narrative style engaging, but didn't enjoy much the actual plot. The setting was promising, but not as magical as I expected coming in. I am curious as to how she gets the name "Lady Trent", but not so much that I would immediately dig into the rest of the series. I'm a bit disappointed I didn't like this more, but maybe I overhyped it by having heard good things on it before
For a full review, check out my blog: strakul.blogspot.com/2016/06/book-review-natural-history-of-dragons.html
I don't know what I was expecting with this book. I had a hard time getting into the writing style, then fell in love with her modern ideas in a victorian setting. I do think I expected more dragons. But I did enjoy her adventures and I rather think I would feel as out of time as she did had I lived in that age. Overall an enjoyable read, but I don't know that I will continue the series.
A brilliant read, refreshing to read a fantasy novel set in a pseudo-Victorian world, with a scientist heroine and a plot that remains riveting without the fate of the world hanging in the balance.