horiaconstantin reviewed Walden by Henry David Thoreau
Doesn't do it for me...
2 stars
It's highly acclaimed, but I don't get it... the language is not that simple to follow. Which makes me not want to read it.
Paperback, 357 pages
Spanish language
Published Sept. 11, 2005 by Cátedra.
Walden está considerada como una obra literaria maestra y como uno de los libros seminales de su siglo. Antiesclavista militante, toda la obra de Henry David Thoreau se centra en la búsqueda de la "vida con principios", principios que serán el criterio de cómo debe ser vivida —con la honradez del trabajo como medio para ganarse la vida—, una vida que él explora y experimenta a través del estudio y la comprensión de la Naturaleza.
El 4 de julio de 1845, Thoreau se traslada a vivir en la cabaña que él mismo había construido en Walden Pond. Durante dos años escribe allí la obra homónima en la que describe su economía doméstica, sus experimentos en agricultura, sus visitantes y vecinos, las plantas y la vida salvaje. La obra de Thoreau es la historia de un experimento original, sin precedentes literarios. Walden es un modo de escribir, de ponerse a "disposición …
Walden está considerada como una obra literaria maestra y como uno de los libros seminales de su siglo. Antiesclavista militante, toda la obra de Henry David Thoreau se centra en la búsqueda de la "vida con principios", principios que serán el criterio de cómo debe ser vivida —con la honradez del trabajo como medio para ganarse la vida—, una vida que él explora y experimenta a través del estudio y la comprensión de la Naturaleza.
El 4 de julio de 1845, Thoreau se traslada a vivir en la cabaña que él mismo había construido en Walden Pond. Durante dos años escribe allí la obra homónima en la que describe su economía doméstica, sus experimentos en agricultura, sus visitantes y vecinos, las plantas y la vida salvaje. La obra de Thoreau es la historia de un experimento original, sin precedentes literarios. Walden es un modo de escribir, de ponerse a "disposición de las palabras", pero también es una Escritura, una forma de aprender lo que la vida tiene que enseñar.
It's highly acclaimed, but I don't get it... the language is not that simple to follow. Which makes me not want to read it.
The emotions while I read this book were bouncing around the room.
One chapter has me yelling in agreement with Thoreau on his pro-animal stances toward hunting and dieting. The next on minimalism - inspiring me to gather more things I no longer need to donate. The next makes me put the book down to be high on nature. The next makes me rethink civil obedience and give up all I’m doing to commit to being my truest self with no external influences.
No review I am able to give can properly outline how impactful this book has been on the way I see the world. The philosophies are still ever true today, and Thoreau’s definition of “dull man” still appears to be the overwhelming majority of society today - all busy slaving away for the objects and powers that only serve to trap and control them.
Excellent read, all …
The emotions while I read this book were bouncing around the room.
One chapter has me yelling in agreement with Thoreau on his pro-animal stances toward hunting and dieting. The next on minimalism - inspiring me to gather more things I no longer need to donate. The next makes me put the book down to be high on nature. The next makes me rethink civil obedience and give up all I’m doing to commit to being my truest self with no external influences.
No review I am able to give can properly outline how impactful this book has been on the way I see the world. The philosophies are still ever true today, and Thoreau’s definition of “dull man” still appears to be the overwhelming majority of society today - all busy slaving away for the objects and powers that only serve to trap and control them.
Excellent read, all should read.
Warning: Definitely on the more difficult side. Though not unattainable.
In Thoreau's most famous book, he creates a space to view the world by moving away from what is accepted as society. For three years he lived in a cabin in Walden, and stripped his life back to essentials, learning to love the world he inhabited.
He shows with a flair for poetry and vocabulary how the local and global can be mingled together, nearly a hundred years before the word 'globalisation' was first used. His interest in philosophical reading stretches across the world, while his interest in experience of the world is limited to a small area. His wry humour and versatile use of the English language makes this not only an enjoyable philosophical text, but also a very enjoyable book overall.
Smart guy gives thoughts on society while in nature.
Having the right expectations before reading Walden helps a lot. I detested it in English class, especially when I learned that Thoreau went into town every other day (mentioned in the book) and was frequently visited by his family with food or went to visit them (not mentioned in the book). While living at Walden he was still more social than the average homebody today. He talks about people more than nature. But my second readthrough—with different expectations—was more enjoyable.
I was relieved to find the literature still met my high standards when Thoreau calls a farmer a skin-flint and describes a baby as a “wrinkled, sibyl-like, cone-headed infant”. Personally, many passages are ok and some, like Thoreau’s view on mornings, reading, and his local town are excellent. Civil Disobedience (22 pages) is a 5/5 and worth rereading periodically. Thoreau’s intelligence …
Smart guy gives thoughts on society while in nature.
Having the right expectations before reading Walden helps a lot. I detested it in English class, especially when I learned that Thoreau went into town every other day (mentioned in the book) and was frequently visited by his family with food or went to visit them (not mentioned in the book). While living at Walden he was still more social than the average homebody today. He talks about people more than nature. But my second readthrough—with different expectations—was more enjoyable.
I was relieved to find the literature still met my high standards when Thoreau calls a farmer a skin-flint and describes a baby as a “wrinkled, sibyl-like, cone-headed infant”. Personally, many passages are ok and some, like Thoreau’s view on mornings, reading, and his local town are excellent. Civil Disobedience (22 pages) is a 5/5 and worth rereading periodically. Thoreau’s intelligence is showcased in this edition's footnotes, which expand on his constant word-play and references to historical figures, literature, religions, mythologies, languages, etc.
Didn't finish it. He seemed rather pretentious and judgmental. Perhaps I'll try again later.
Dear Henry,
I'm so sorry, but your book was not what I was hoping for. I thought it would be a story of survival, of reflection, of getting back to nature. There was a little of the reflection and nature, to be sure. But seriously, Thoreau, you were right outside of town. You were near the railroad tracks. You were BORROWING someone's land. Not exactly roughing it, were you? You entertained friends and really didn't get away from it all like you seemed to think.
I don't think it was you, friend. I think it was me. I went in with high expectations, and came away underwhelmed. No hard feelings?
Thoreau chose to live deliberately and to observe life from a fresh perspective, as though no one had ever done so before. The result was a high quality of intimate thought, written for both the reader's challenge and enjoyment. In order to get the most from Walden, it is necessary to slow down and read deliberately. Thoreau carefully studied varied aspects of the natural world, reminding us how interesting everything is and how each moment of our lives can be full of discovery and wonder.