Review of 'The City and the Stars / The Sands of Mars' on 'Goodreads'
2 stars
I'm afraid that this was just a huge disappointment for me. I recommend passing it by... too little, too boring, not very interesting.
529 pages
English language
Published Aug. 7, 2001 by Aspect/Warner Books.
I'm afraid that this was just a huge disappointment for me. I recommend passing it by... too little, too boring, not very interesting.
A vision of the deep future that is both grand and disappointingly tame. At its heart it's a coming of age adventure story where a grand mystery leads to some post apocalyptic expeditions, and eventually some deep space archaeology. The parts are loosely enough connected that it feels like it may have been originally published as a serial, or that he was writing as he went along to see where he ended up.
Some of the details are prescient, others are the introduction of tropes that are now well worn in the genre. As usual, women are mostly token trophies with whatever agency they have undercut by the protagonist, though theyy're is a burgeoning bromance that feels like it would be at the heart of a modern iteration of this book.
Interesting as a foundational piece of science fiction, but a bit tedious by modern standards.
Brilliant!
Un roman de science-fiction d'Arthur C. Clarke, poétique et intéressant. Un peu naïf et maladroit par moment, mais plutôt prenant dans l'ensemble. Ni totalement inoubliable, ni complètement transparent, de la science-fiction à la fois classique et atypique, à vrai dire.