Tracker is known far and wide for his skills as a hunter: "He has a nose," people say. Engaged to track down a mysterious boy who disappeared three years earlier, Tracker breaks his own rule of always working alone when he finds himself part of a group that comes together to search for the boy. The band is a hodgepodge, full of unusual characters with secrets of their own, including a shape-shifting man-animal known as Leopard. As Tracker follows the boy's scent--from one ancient city to another; into dense forests and across deep rivers--he and the band are set upon by creatures intent on destroying them. As he struggles to survive, Tracker starts to wonder: Who, really, is this boy? Why has he been missing for so long? Why do so many people want to keep Tracker from finding him? And perhaps the most important questions of all: Who is …
Tracker is known far and wide for his skills as a hunter: "He has a nose," people say. Engaged to track down a mysterious boy who disappeared three years earlier, Tracker breaks his own rule of always working alone when he finds himself part of a group that comes together to search for the boy. The band is a hodgepodge, full of unusual characters with secrets of their own, including a shape-shifting man-animal known as Leopard. As Tracker follows the boy's scent--from one ancient city to another; into dense forests and across deep rivers--he and the band are set upon by creatures intent on destroying them. As he struggles to survive, Tracker starts to wonder: Who, really, is this boy? Why has he been missing for so long? Why do so many people want to keep Tracker from finding him? And perhaps the most important questions of all: Who is telling the truth, and who is lying? Drawing from African history and mythology and his own rich imagination, Marlon James has written a novel unlike anything that's come before it: a saga of breathtaking adventure that's also an ambitious, involving read. Defying categorization and full of unforgettable characters, Black Leopard, Red Wolf is both surprising and profound as it explores the fundamentals of truth, the limits of power, and our need to understand them both.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
I respect this book more than I love it. It's a fresh take on the fantasy genre with extremely vivid settings and characters and some seriously brutal violence. At the same time, it never really hooked me and by the end it didn't feel like the sum was greater than the parts.
I'm sure there's an argument for it being the point but to me it felt like - after the first 200 or so pages - you could put this book down at any time and you'd be taking away as much as someone who read the whole thing.
I think it took me about 350 pages before finally getting sucked into the story.
But when I finally got into to it, I finally found all the details fascinating. The story gets moving, full of action, stories, unique fiction, persona and lore. This is definitely something that should be read by all that love fantasy.
I usually drop fiction that hits me with too much magic up front, but this was so foreign, irreverent, and unpredictable that it kept me curious. Having finished it I really feel like I've spent time in an alien world. I'm not sure I like or understand all of it, but the exposure forced my mind to broaden somehow.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
2019 - I feel like I may upgrade my opinion of this one after it's had some time to sink in.
2022 - Yup. Reread this in anticipation of reading the sequel and definitely liked it more the second time around. There's quite a bit about the story that's deliberately opaque (i.e. the identity of the boy the main characters all seek), or runs off along tangents (i.e. I hope the business with Tracker's wolf eye has some relevance in the sequel), and piecing all that together while also acclimating to the idiosyncrasies of the author and the narrator (for example, James likes long conversations between pairs of characters where the speakers alternate without ever identifying who is saying which line of dialog) sort of made me bounce off it the first time. Much better the second time around, armed with familiarity.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
No rating
March 09, 2022: DNF on page 35/620 Not sure I’ll have the patience to return to this one even though I’m a tad curious. Definitely not the right moment now though
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
Disclaimer: I did not read the book but listened to the audiobook (with a brilliant narrator), and I'm not sure I'd have made it through if I'd read it due to the horrendously and powerfully graphic violence in this. Yes, I admit I might be squeamish. Yes, I had to turn the audiobook off and take a break after various torture scenes because the narrator was being too realistic for my poor mind.
That said, let me reiterate that the comparison to ASoIaF is uncalled-for, and honestly unfair - at least from the point of view of somebody who didn't particularly enjoy most of that unfinished [censored]. For one thing, the female characters in this book are powerful and cunning - though, admittedly, often on the fiendishly evil side of things. And the male main/narrator character, Tracker, usually gets the short end of the stick in conflicts there. Personally, …
Disclaimer: I did not read the book but listened to the audiobook (with a brilliant narrator), and I'm not sure I'd have made it through if I'd read it due to the horrendously and powerfully graphic violence in this. Yes, I admit I might be squeamish. Yes, I had to turn the audiobook off and take a break after various torture scenes because the narrator was being too realistic for my poor mind.
That said, let me reiterate that the comparison to ASoIaF is uncalled-for, and honestly unfair - at least from the point of view of somebody who didn't particularly enjoy most of that unfinished [censored]. For one thing, the female characters in this book are powerful and cunning - though, admittedly, often on the fiendishly evil side of things. And the male main/narrator character, Tracker, usually gets the short end of the stick in conflicts there. Personally, I do appreciate capable female villains (which possibly is the main reason for my eternal disappointment in Cersei), and I like it when ruthlessness isn't attributed to one gender only. Here, everybody gets to be successfully wicked.
I'd also like to focus on Tracker himself for a moment whose mysogenistic world view becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy to haunt his existence up until the point when he faces it for what it really is, in his case: the lingering disappointment and distrust of a child due to unresolved issues with his mother. This actually becomes a topic in the context of the brief period in which Tracker is actually allowed by the author to experience happiness and fulfillment. The quest (which is the main plot of the book, but only starts a good while in) seemed almost as much a quest for identity and belonging for him as it is the classical "future of the kingdom/world" trope of fantasy literature. Tracker also is the "red wolf" of the title - given a wolf-eye by a sangoma after having lost one eye to hyenas after a friend betrays him, he has a nose and uses (and is used for) this to find the lost for money; red because of the red earth used as "body painting" by the people he hails from. And he definitely has anger-management-issues. The other part of the title is, surprisingly, the Leopard - a black one. There's no other name given, and he is, after all, a leopard who has the ability to take human form. The friendship dynamics of the two eponymic characters are complicated, not purely for intrinsic reasons, but the bond is undeniably strong. So much so that the Leopard dies in the end, trying to help Tracker despite having been on opposing sides merely moments before. Surprisingly, he often almost acts as a comic relief despite his importance.
The language of the characters varies strongly according to what kind of formal education and/or intellectual capacities are attributed to them. And also according to their position in this society. There is, as in many novels of the "writing back" tradition with oppressors and oppressed, a language of the powerful and one of the powerless. It is a powerful characterization tool, and far too seldom-used, especially in such less "academic" genres as fantasy.
There are many more topics that are dealt with within the narration without being shoved in in an unnatural way (gender-roles, what makes a man a man, and many others), and there seems to be a lot of controversy around this book with people either celebrating it or completely rejecting it, and no middle ground. I won't go into either of these things because this would get annoyingly long.
Lastly, I want to praise the narrator of the audiobook again. This is the first time ever I had the experience of one single person giving characters different voices without the characters sounding far too alike after all, or it being just silly.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
This is a very good book.
Like most good books, it is a weaving.
Set in an imaginary "Africa" before the European came - their arrival is foreshadowed - it is the story of a quest, undertaken by a young man who is simply known as tracker. He recounts his story to an inquisitor who, we understand, holds the man's life in his hands. If he is to remain alive, he must tell his stories. The stories are fantastical, full of occult beasts and various modes of UnDead. They may be pure invention, a psychotic fantasy designed to detract from a sordid history of infanticide and rape.
The book is not for the faint-hearted. We are down in Sade's dungeons where the odour is foul and rank. The tracker is gifted - or cursed - with a supernatural sense of smell, and most of what he smells is bad. There …
This is a very good book.
Like most good books, it is a weaving.
Set in an imaginary "Africa" before the European came - their arrival is foreshadowed - it is the story of a quest, undertaken by a young man who is simply known as tracker. He recounts his story to an inquisitor who, we understand, holds the man's life in his hands. If he is to remain alive, he must tell his stories. The stories are fantastical, full of occult beasts and various modes of UnDead. They may be pure invention, a psychotic fantasy designed to detract from a sordid history of infanticide and rape.
The book is not for the faint-hearted. We are down in Sade's dungeons where the odour is foul and rank. The tracker is gifted - or cursed - with a supernatural sense of smell, and most of what he smells is bad. There are many acts of violence and cruelty. This is not a nursery fairy-tale.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Storygraph'
No rating
I’m uncomfortable with the sheer number of descriptions of things that somehow involve people’s bodies in a sexual manner even when nothing sexual is even happening. It felt like everything was couched in terms of a male/female binary. The thing that made me stop was one character’s casual description of circumcision and female genital mutilation as equivalent and positive things to do to children’s bodies. It’s possible that the overall stance of the book doesn’t condone this (authors are not their characters, after all), but I’m too distressed to read more and find out.
I’m uncomfortable with the sheer number of descriptions of things that somehow involve people’s bodies in a sexual manner even when nothing sexual is even happening. It felt like everything was couched in terms of a male/female binary. The thing that made me stop was one character’s casual description of circumcision and female genital mutilation as equivalent and positive things to do to children’s bodies. It’s possible that the overall stance of the book doesn’t condone this (authors are not their characters, after all), but I’m too distressed to read more and find out.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
I honestly don't know what to think about this book. At first, I found it confusing. Then a while in I got into its groove and enjoyed it. Then found it a confusing again. The language can be hard to follow sometimes, which can be disjointing given that it seems to want to sort of be an adventure/action type thing and does at times flow in such a way, but then it constantly morphs and plays in other more complicated ways. Definitely worth reading and grappling with but I'm not sure it lived up to the critical praise for me. But maybe I missed something and need to reread it to really get it? Not sure.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
No rating
DNF
Nope! Couldn't do it. Got about 120 pages in and just couldn't get over the misogyny, graphic sex, domestic violence, and disturbing fixation on genital mutilation. I don't like the style of writing which makes it difficult to figure out what is actually happening.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
1 star
The opening chapter contains detailed reference to sexual assaults of such horrific depravity I dropped the book and went to research it again because HOW was this the buzzed about “modern day mythology” new “Lord of the Rings” I’d seen it called??
From what I’ve read in reviews this is just the tip of the iceberg for an onslaught of lovingly described dehumanizing torture and assault entirely unnecessary to the plot and so so SO not for me.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
No rating
DNF. Wasn't for me, at least not in my current state of mind-- extremely graphic and surprisingly difficult to follow, despite being intriguing. May revisit later.
Review of 'Black Leopard, Red Wolf' on 'Goodreads'
1 star
Pretentious meandering prose and constant sexual violence.
Disappointing, as I was looking forward to African myth and got patois nonsense instead. After a genuine attempt and 250 pages, I am going to give up on this book.