loppear reviewed Children of Ruin by Adrian Tchaikovsky
Review of "Children of Ruin"
3 stars
Does not have the rhythm of the first book, explores memory and simulation more with some good story threads but fell short for me.
English language
Published Nov. 28, 2019 by Orbit.
Does not have the rhythm of the first book, explores memory and simulation more with some good story threads but fell short for me.
I had looked forward to this sequel. Sadly, I found this novel disappointing. The plot line was 'awkward' and did not seem to come to a logical stopping point. The characters were not well developed and/or robust, perhaps due in part to the overly abundant plot lines.
Oh well...
2022 Dec:
I had forgotten that the epilogue of this book already contained corvids in what was basically a teaser for the next book.
I think upon second reading feels more soft-sci-fi than first, but really cool and with all kinds of things I love still.
2020 Feb:
The draw in these books for me are the "others", and they are done so credibly well! There's some tension and some solution which is less interesting than the idea of how differently intelligence might work. I love these books.
The author has a vicious imagination reasonably grounded by science. The story switches back and forth between two timelines; depending on your preference the cliff hangers could make it hard to put it down or impossible to pick it up. I loved it. I tried cheating, too eager to find out what happened. Let me warn you right now - the timelines are intertwined and it’s hard to follow if you skip and hop.
This is the sequel to "Children of Time" and you should definitely read the first book before reading this one or it won't make a lot of sense. But read the first one, it's also an amazing book, and then come back and read this one!
"Children of Ruin" mirrors the structure of "Children of Time" by jumping between two different time periods - the far past and the near present, which slowly converge over the course of the book as we see how they relate. The "far past" section deals with another terraforming ship, colleagues of Dr. Kern from "Children of Time", who went to a different planet with the intent to terraform it, only to find it already inhabited by non-intelligent life, the first actual alien life anyone has found. Rather than destroy it to make a new world for humans, they opt to terraform another planet in …
This is the sequel to "Children of Time" and you should definitely read the first book before reading this one or it won't make a lot of sense. But read the first one, it's also an amazing book, and then come back and read this one!
"Children of Ruin" mirrors the structure of "Children of Time" by jumping between two different time periods - the far past and the near present, which slowly converge over the course of the book as we see how they relate. The "far past" section deals with another terraforming ship, colleagues of Dr. Kern from "Children of Time", who went to a different planet with the intent to terraform it, only to find it already inhabited by non-intelligent life, the first actual alien life anyone has found. Rather than destroy it to make a new world for humans, they opt to terraform another planet in the same system that is less habitable due to being mostly ocean, but unoccupied. One team goes to investigate the occupied world, while a second team works on the terraforming, and because it is a water world, includes the creation of an uplifted breed of octopus intended to be the humans' helpers.
Without getting into too many spoilers, things go badly wrong, and many thousands of years later when a joint Human/Portiid expedition from Kern's World arrives in the system, they find a race of spacefaring octopods who are so panicked by the sight of a human being that it sparks a violent space battle and the remainder of the book involves the Kern's World alliance trying to figure out how to communicate with octopods, and why the sight of a human and even the suggestion of them visiting either of the populated worlds in the system induces terror to the point of open warfare.
I loved the spiders in "Children of Time" and the way Tchaikovsky believably describes their evolution into an intelligent, tool-using civilization without losing their spider-ness, and the only thing that could have delighted me more than the Portiid race is when he does just as well with the intelligent octopods. This book also has some moments of serious creepiness which were chilling and scary, and plenty of action as well as a thoughtful discussion of the problems of communication that would obviously exist when Humans, Portiids, and octopods attempt to learn to communicate. Dr. Kern is back also in ship's-computer form, and also a key part of the plot.
I felt the ending was resolved a little quickly and a bit predictably if you'd read the first book, as there are many parallels between the structure of the first book and this sequel. However, still lots of great and unique details along the way and some really alien aliens, so if you loved the first book this one is a must-read too. Definitely leaves room open for another sequel also.
Tchaikovsky is really good at bringing to life non human consciousness. This time it's octopuses|i|odes, and it's as good as children of time.