The Soul of A New Machine

I loved this book, and I don't think I've ever read, seen or heard such detailed accounts of the goings-on in a tech company and between engineers. There have been several movies or shows which focus on the engineers during the silicon valley gold rush (and I've seen maybe a couple of them), but I don't think any of them have accounts like those presented in the book. It's vivid, and does not shy away from really talking about the things that the engineers did, or struggled with, or what was really; same goes for what was going at the management and the interpersonal stuff between the employees at the company that Tracy spent a long time with.

A little background: the book was published in 1981, and the company that Tracy is documenting is 'Data General', a company that was making a new computer at the time. The company no longer exists just like many others at the time.

I highly recommend this book to any engineers who really want to know how it would have felt like at the time to be working on building a computer at such a place at such a time -- something like that is basically no longer possible, things are similar now, but also quite different.

Original: ntavish.in/blog/2024_books/#the-soul-of-a-new-machine-by-tracy-kidder

Still a wild tale, I’m no longer in awe of it and it’s obvious everyone involved got screwed and feels good about it (though that might be the authors bias). The love of the work “I’d take a pay cut to be involved in a project like this again” when already underpaid. It’s wild.

"West" one of the project leaders goes into “business development” answering the question “what happens to engineers over 40” writes Kidder. Fuck that. He doesn’t want to be exploited any longer, that’s what happens when you get over 40. Seems he’s still in engineering anyway consulting with other teams.

Overall this is a Wild take on a time in engineering that is not dissimilar to some companies today. I’ve worked at Data General clones, it sucks and isn’t worth it. Don’t get romanced. This is a cautionary tale told as an adventure story. I’m glad to revisit it after 20 odd years and I'm glad to see how my perspective has shifted.

Perhaps this review is biased by being in the software industry but it's find a more riveting read about how the computery sausage is made. An elegant, yet realistic writing style, it resonates decades later with important discussions on labor and finding meaning in post-industrial society.

Tracy Kidder recounts the uber-enjoyable events of an engineering team racing to build a microcomputer, making it feel like you're the geeked intern spectating at all the engineers in wonder and delight. The personalities, the hardware, the business, the goofs and the gaffes pull you in and never really lets go. Now, forty years later, the book is old and the technology is practically archaic, however, nothing seems to have really changed.

Good read. I'm not sure if it would have been so enjoyable for someone who isn't a computer programmer.

This is a classic computer history book but unique in the fact that it was written while the Data General Eclipse MV/8000 (code named Eagle) was being developed in the 1979-1980 time frame. This was DG's answer to DEC's VAX and their first 32-bit machine. Kidder was embedded with the team as a journalist with no computer background whatsoever. This comes in handy because computers were exotic things which most people had only seen in movies. It is hard to imagine, even for someone like me that was a computer obsessed kid in that era but he's describing floppy disks as "an object almost the exact shape and size as a 45-rpm record" or a hard disk module as a football helmet. He describes what computer memory in details that make it sound huge for the day but are 1000s of times smaller than today. However the level of detail of the engineering but in layman's terms are great too. I'm not a hardware person so reading about how they would build and debug a computer like that in that era is totally foreign to me, so this was very insightful. He didn't just cover the tech aspects though. He got into the backgrounds of the major players, the political corporate dynamics, and the mindset of engineers. Even though the computers and software we build today are radically different in scale it is fascinating how much of it is the same. This is a five star book for anyone with a moderate interest in computer history or maybe even business history, since it details business side stuff too, including some shady stuff DG did in the early-70s that I didn't know about. If it isn't an area of interest it will probably seem too slow or dry because you get way in the weeds on all of the little details. I wish more books about computer history were written this way. It really put you into the moment since it was literally written embedded with the team in that moment.

This book is beautifully written. I reads like a wistful memoir for the life of a machine. The story is of the creation of Project Eagle in the Late 70's/Early 80's at Data General. If you are interested in computers, their history, or how they were dreamed up and made, this is essential reading. I loved reading about the creation of a computer during the age when people thought that they were going to be the impetus of revolution. This is really a love letter for the wild-west age of computing.

I have complicated feelings about this book, which I read when I was just starting my career in tech and re-read this week after 30ish years. On the one hand: it is a super-compelling nerd fable, and some of the best layman's descriptions of computer engineering ever written. On the other: A total blueprint for for how to sign tech workers up for abusive working conditions, and convince them that it is all about the passion. I need to sit with it for a while.

This is a special book that captures a time not to long ago in human years, but ancient history in tech years - an era that I believe is woefully under-documented in comparison to the life and times of the personal computer.

Kidder takes a banal subject, the engineering of a minicomputer, and captures the heart behind the effort. It also manages to be an insight into management techniques and technical processes, but never gets bogged down in either one.

Kidder romances a little too much for my taste and sometimes it's difficult to keep track of the engineers and get a feel for their idiosyncrasies. However, it's probably the best book of its kind and his ability to tell a nimble story is superb.

This was recommended to me from the Amazon workplace article a few weeks back. Here is a great tale from 1980 of a tech company embracing the startup-competition-80hr-weeks method to push out a new computer under arbitrary deadlines, to hire smart kids and work them incessantly for the joy of getting to do something cool. All interwoven with a very detailed but hopefully readable account of how computers worked and were built at this mid-point in their history. I could relate to pretty much everything in here - hope I'm more of a Carl Alsing than anyone else, but still a world I'm happy to be looking mostly backwards to now. Tracy Kidder had great access during and after, a really well told story that is still all too relevant.