kim karma reviewed Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro
Review of 'Klara and the Sun' on 'Goodreads'
DNF. Some books just aren't for me.
Paperback
English language
Published March 1, 2021 by FABER ET FABER.
Klara and the Sun is the eighth novel by the Nobel Prize-winning British writer Kazuo Ishiguro, published on 2 March 2021. It is a dystopian science fiction story. Set in the U.S. in an unspecified future, the book is told from the point of view of Klara, a solar-powered AF (Artificial Friend), who is chosen by Josie, a sickly child, to be her companion. The novel was longlisted for the 2021 Booker Prize.
DNF. Some books just aren't for me.
El libro esta muy bien me encanto la historia el final bueno me dejo un sabor de boca un tanto curioso pero estuvo bien es una aventura en la cual vi al final que realmente las personas que te quieren son un elemento que contribuye a hacerte unico y que cosas como los AA si existieran me gustaria que pudieran integrarse mas en nuestra sociedad creo que seria un gran avance
Interesting take on the depth of human mind set in a dystopian world and written from the eyes of an artificial friend.
Read this mostly as a bedtime read, which it was good for - pretty easy and not too creepy (although slightly unsettling at times). It nodded to a few things that piqued my interest (AI, eco-sabotage, transhumanism?) But didn't really flesh out any of them, they were mostly just a vibe/backdrop for the story of the characters, which was fine. Ive really enjoyed some books that explore human-robot interactions - marge piercey's body of glass comes to mind - but this didn't quite do it for me in terms of making my brain stretch around those questions of how we relate to machines. Which I don't think was the point of the book, I think the point was to build the world up from the perceptions of the narrator (an android) and that part was done quite well.
Overall a totally fine read and well-written but just didn't scratch anything …
Read this mostly as a bedtime read, which it was good for - pretty easy and not too creepy (although slightly unsettling at times). It nodded to a few things that piqued my interest (AI, eco-sabotage, transhumanism?) But didn't really flesh out any of them, they were mostly just a vibe/backdrop for the story of the characters, which was fine. Ive really enjoyed some books that explore human-robot interactions - marge piercey's body of glass comes to mind - but this didn't quite do it for me in terms of making my brain stretch around those questions of how we relate to machines. Which I don't think was the point of the book, I think the point was to build the world up from the perceptions of the narrator (an android) and that part was done quite well.
Overall a totally fine read and well-written but just didn't scratch anything super interesting in my brain.
¿Cómo definir Klara y el Sol?
Quizá sea una novela de anticipación.
Ishiguro ha logrado aquí, en mi humilde opinión, la perfección en la sencillez.
Narra un panorama inquietante pero lo hace bellamente, porque lo narra desde la luminosa mirada de Klara, una "niñoide" (creo que he inventado una palabra) del tamaño de un hobbit y el pelo a lo bob, dotada de una verdadera inteligencia artificial programada para ser sensible y amable compañera de juegos de una niña, una de lo que sería la "clase media" del futuro cercano.
Inocente y amable, Klara nos muestra lo que ve y a través de sus ojos conocemos su mundo, uno vivo, humano y jodidamente posible. De alguna manera, la novela consigue ser realista, quizá porque incluye también lo maravilloso.
No os esperéis aventuras ni cosas espectaculares o grandilocuentes. Es entre sus líneas donde Ishiguro nos muestra el terror. Uno verdadero, cotidiano, …
¿Cómo definir Klara y el Sol?
Quizá sea una novela de anticipación.
Ishiguro ha logrado aquí, en mi humilde opinión, la perfección en la sencillez.
Narra un panorama inquietante pero lo hace bellamente, porque lo narra desde la luminosa mirada de Klara, una "niñoide" (creo que he inventado una palabra) del tamaño de un hobbit y el pelo a lo bob, dotada de una verdadera inteligencia artificial programada para ser sensible y amable compañera de juegos de una niña, una de lo que sería la "clase media" del futuro cercano.
Inocente y amable, Klara nos muestra lo que ve y a través de sus ojos conocemos su mundo, uno vivo, humano y jodidamente posible. De alguna manera, la novela consigue ser realista, quizá porque incluye también lo maravilloso.
No os esperéis aventuras ni cosas espectaculares o grandilocuentes. Es entre sus líneas donde Ishiguro nos muestra el terror. Uno verdadero, cotidiano, que puede llegar a pasar. Y a través de él, sin acritud, nos conmina, irremediablemente, a pensar sobre qué futuro queremos para nuestros hijos.
Todo es cuestión de gustos, claro está, pero este es, desde luego, un gran libro.
Love, hope, empathy. Some of the most important human traits, and yet often they are tossed away in moments of fear as desperation. Klara, a clever, very human seeming AF (artificial friend) , complete with her own version of cosmology, lives a quiet life where such questions circle around her, and she does her best to remind the humans she interacts with of their own nature, with varying degrees of success, and quite a bit of failure. Be prepared for Ishiguro’s tendency to never fully explain the world his stories take place in. If you’re the kind of reader who needs explicit answers, this is not the right book for you.
Ish returns to central questions about the nature of humanness using his simple style, the tool of the removed narrator, and, most importantly, as he did in Never Let Me Go a setting in the near future where he uses an aspect of technology as a magnifying glass. If we create a true artificial intelligence, what will it think about to itself? What will it see about us that we do not see ourselves? How will we use it? How will we discard it, as we discard everything that we have no immediate use for?
An introspective, meditative novel that sacrifices maybe a bit too much world building and exposition to provide instead reflections of reflections of the themes it actually wants to tackle when it comes to society and technology. I think I ultimately disagree with the points it's trying to make, but I can't really be sure what those points are, or if there's a degree of cowardice in never saying them out loud because they'd be revealed to be of the "old man yelling at cloud" variety. Regardless, I really enjoyed the protagonist, Klara really propels the book forward from beginning to end, and the plot has a nice cadence that kept the momentum going for me.
Klara and the Sun is a bittersweet book about an Artificial Friend, the lengths parents go to and what makes us human. It is also possibly a cautionary tale on not topping up your vitamin D in winter, but maybe I feel that way as we creep out of winter and remember what the sun feels like…
To Klara, the Sun is almost godlike. He provides her nourishment, implying that she’s solar powered, but she also thinks she sees the Sun bring a homeless man back to life. This event shapes Klara’s belief over the rest of the book.
It’s told in first person narrative from Klara’s point of view, and she is naïve but lovely. She’s been designed to hang out with kids, to be a good influence on them, although Josie is a teenager, old enough that Klara much watch over her and Rick for fear of hanky-panky. …
Klara and the Sun is a bittersweet book about an Artificial Friend, the lengths parents go to and what makes us human. It is also possibly a cautionary tale on not topping up your vitamin D in winter, but maybe I feel that way as we creep out of winter and remember what the sun feels like…
To Klara, the Sun is almost godlike. He provides her nourishment, implying that she’s solar powered, but she also thinks she sees the Sun bring a homeless man back to life. This event shapes Klara’s belief over the rest of the book.
It’s told in first person narrative from Klara’s point of view, and she is naïve but lovely. She’s been designed to hang out with kids, to be a good influence on them, although Josie is a teenager, old enough that Klara much watch over her and Rick for fear of hanky-panky. Klara really does care for Josie, above all others. She is her purpose in life, so when she ails, Klara must find a way to help.
Klara may be an older model, but she is very perceptive, learning how to read the humans closest to her. She tries to work people out, to better understand them and make sure she does the best job she can.
There is also a story of class divides, the haves and have nots. Josie’s friend, Rick, has not been “lifted” and he is viewed with suspicion because of this. He is treated as a second-class citizen, not eligible for most universities despite his intelligence and skills. It’s easy to guess what being lifted involves, and it is revealed briefly later on, but what is important is that it creates a divide in society.
I wasn’t too keen on what happened with Rick’s mother, there’s a scene that’s just awkward and I’m not sure of the relevance. She is trying her best to give Rick an advantage, or make him have slightly less disadvantage, yet she is made out to be the bad one in the scene. Maybe she shouldn’t have done what she did but who can blame her.
I suppose with both Rick’s mother and Josie’s father, these characters are barely known by Klara. Her knowledge is childlike, so when something is revealed about them that seems sudden, it may just be that she’s been shielded from this, or just not been privy to what they’re really like. I did find these things jarring though, and not necessarily all that important to have included.
First posted at Curiosity Killed the Bookworm.