brenticus reviewed Candide, or, Optimism by Voltaire (Barnes & Noble classics)
Critique and validation?
5 stars
In a thin volume, Voltaire puts forth what I would call a tour de force on the philosophy of optimism. Much of this is critique, no doubt; it is trivial to see how this clearly isn't the best of all possible worlds, and all things clearly don't happen for the best. There are innumerable places throughout the story where bad things happen that outright make things worse, despite any silver lining Candide can find in it, and it is entirely conceivable that the bad things did not need to happen.
That said, Voltaire does not treat things pessimistically. No one really "bottoms out" in the end, and Candide is able to make a living for himself and his friends and family that is good enough. Certainly, it isn't the extravagance of the Baron's manor or the hospitality of El Dorado, but he is able to engage in his favourite activity …
In a thin volume, Voltaire puts forth what I would call a tour de force on the philosophy of optimism. Much of this is critique, no doubt; it is trivial to see how this clearly isn't the best of all possible worlds, and all things clearly don't happen for the best. There are innumerable places throughout the story where bad things happen that outright make things worse, despite any silver lining Candide can find in it, and it is entirely conceivable that the bad things did not need to happen.
That said, Voltaire does not treat things pessimistically. No one really "bottoms out" in the end, and Candide is able to make a living for himself and his friends and family that is good enough. Certainly, it isn't the extravagance of the Baron's manor or the hospitality of El Dorado, but he is able to engage in his favourite activity of philosophizing, make a living with his own labour, and exist without undue hardship.
Candide may not be entirely happy with this, but how many of his companions did he leave for dead along the way and find again? How many times was he on the brink of utter disaster? Happiness is relative, in many ways, and while Candide could never reach the best of all possible worlds he could at least carve out a good enough one for himself.