paven reviewed The Hero of Ages by Brandon Sanderson (Mistborn Era One, #3)
Review of 'The Hero of Ages' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
I love that magic is taken seriously, and a presented in a way that makes sense. Great epic storyline.
760 pages
Spanish language
Published April 15, 2021 by Ediciones B Mexico.
This book is not only the third book in a trilogy, but it’s Act Three of the the three-act structure for the Mistborn Trilogy—it’s the part of the story where the heroes have discovered that what they thought was the problem all along was not the true danger, and now they’re fighting for not only their own survival but that of the world they live in. The mists are killing people and staying out much longer than they should. The Ashmounts are spewing more and more choking ash into the sky, burying the crops that everyone needs to eat to live. And Ruin, the creature Vin was tricked into freeing from its prison of a millennium, is loose to wreak havoc upon the land. Life under the Lord Ruler is starting to look like paradise in comparison.
While the first book in the trilogy turned the standard fantasy story on …
This book is not only the third book in a trilogy, but it’s Act Three of the the three-act structure for the Mistborn Trilogy—it’s the part of the story where the heroes have discovered that what they thought was the problem all along was not the true danger, and now they’re fighting for not only their own survival but that of the world they live in. The mists are killing people and staying out much longer than they should. The Ashmounts are spewing more and more choking ash into the sky, burying the crops that everyone needs to eat to live. And Ruin, the creature Vin was tricked into freeing from its prison of a millennium, is loose to wreak havoc upon the land. Life under the Lord Ruler is starting to look like paradise in comparison.
While the first book in the trilogy turned the standard fantasy story on its head, this volume (perhaps inevitably?) returns in a way to the tropes the first volume was a reaction against. Yet in this case the enemy is not a human or humanlike Dark Lord, but something more like a force of nature—entropy itself given a will and a guiding personality in the form of Ruin.
Ultimately, the book is about how the characters we have grown to love from the previous volumes—Vin, Elend, Sazed, TenSoon, Spook, Marsh, and others—find the courage and faith to fight on in the face of overwhelming odds, just as Kelsier taught them when he plotted the downfall of the Final Empire.
I love that magic is taken seriously, and a presented in a way that makes sense. Great epic storyline.
Contrairement aux deux premiers tomes qui m'avaient tout de suite embarqué, celui-ci m'a semblé un peu long à démarrer. Par contre, une fois qu'il est lancé, le récit devient épique, digne de ce qu'on attend du dernier volume d'une trilogie de fantasy.
Comme pour chacun des deux premiers tomes, Brandon Sanderson utilise des clichés de la fantasy pour les détourner et nous induire en erreur. Evidemment, comme c'est le troisième roman de la trilogie, j'ai été un peu plus méfiant et attentif au détail, ce qui fait que je n'ai été qu'à moitié surpris par la révélation finale, mais cela n'enlève rien au résultat : captivant et terriblement épique.
Dans l'ensemble, nous avons affaire ici à une très bonne trilogie de fantasy, qui a réussi à me réconcilier avec un genre dont je m'étais lassé. Je sais que l'auteur a écrit d'autres romans dans le même univers, mais se déroulant …
Contrairement aux deux premiers tomes qui m'avaient tout de suite embarqué, celui-ci m'a semblé un peu long à démarrer. Par contre, une fois qu'il est lancé, le récit devient épique, digne de ce qu'on attend du dernier volume d'une trilogie de fantasy.
Comme pour chacun des deux premiers tomes, Brandon Sanderson utilise des clichés de la fantasy pour les détourner et nous induire en erreur. Evidemment, comme c'est le troisième roman de la trilogie, j'ai été un peu plus méfiant et attentif au détail, ce qui fait que je n'ai été qu'à moitié surpris par la révélation finale, mais cela n'enlève rien au résultat : captivant et terriblement épique.
Dans l'ensemble, nous avons affaire ici à une très bonne trilogie de fantasy, qui a réussi à me réconcilier avec un genre dont je m'étais lassé. Je sais que l'auteur a écrit d'autres romans dans le même univers, mais se déroulant plusieurs siècles plus tard : je les lirai sans doute dans quelque temps, en espérant y prendre autant de plaisir qu'avec cette excellente trilogie.
What an ending... or last book of the series! Many books jump to answers and the reader is at a loss for an explanation, not here. All the clues were right in front of my face the entire time. You can tell this book was planned out. Things that happened in the first chapters of the first book make so much impact and are wrapped up unlike any other series I have read. It ends not as expected, or as I expected, but was brilliant. Really would like to know how Sanderson did this! No question about it, I will read his other series.
This was a fantastic conclusion to the Mistborn trilogy. There were times where I could see where the characters were going and what they would have to do before they did, which was ok because the journey was still entertaining. Brandon mentions in the preface that he was not originally satisfied with Sazed's story arc - whatever it was before he finished the book, I'm glad he fixed it. Brandon also left an easy opening for follow-on story that will be very different.
Fantastic ending to a suspenseful trilogy.
This was a fantastic conclusion to the Mistborn trilogy. There were times where I could see where the characters were going and what they would have to do before they did, which was ok because the journey was still entertaining. Brandon mentions in the preface that he was not originally satisfied with Sazed's story arc - whatever it was before he finished the book, I'm glad he fixed it. Brandon also left an easy opening for follow-on story that will be very different.
Fantastic ending to a suspenseful trilogy.
"The world was ending, and its gods had to die with it"
Now that's a way to wrap things up neatly.
Neat character arcs. Lots of action. Sazed's repetitive contemplation sits in stark contrast to the pacing of the other characters, but the depiction of his depression and the payoff of it all is glorious.
I'm not a fan of Sanderson's prose, so I'm hesitant to pick up the other books in this universe. Even after the tantalizing setup at the end of this book.
PS: I still think Book 2 was largely pointless. So much could have been written on the psyche of the skaa and the nobility after 1000 years of stability and oppression, and the political questions that arise after that event. Playing out those questions only in Elend's head - punctuated by declarations from Tindwyl - made it terrible. The sparseness of Book 2 made for a tight Book 3 though, and I'm thankful for these small mercies.
Satisfying conclusion to the trilogy. Sandborn is primarily a world-building guy and this book, like his others, is far stronger on the consistency of magic rules and mechanics of power than it is in characters. There are some good exceptions though; Sazed's transformation through the book is well done if a little tiring at times as he sorts through every single religion in his memory for reasons to dismiss them. Spook is probably the best character in this book. The dialog is still rather stilted though and the characters are not the strongest point -- but this trilogy-finale ties up so many little loose ends that you didn't even were loose ends all the way back to the first book, that it's very satisfying anyway. And I did not see the final plot points coming, which I always appreciate. If Sanderson ever learns how to write people as well as …
Satisfying conclusion to the trilogy. Sandborn is primarily a world-building guy and this book, like his others, is far stronger on the consistency of magic rules and mechanics of power than it is in characters. There are some good exceptions though; Sazed's transformation through the book is well done if a little tiring at times as he sorts through every single religion in his memory for reasons to dismiss them. Spook is probably the best character in this book. The dialog is still rather stilted though and the characters are not the strongest point -- but this trilogy-finale ties up so many little loose ends that you didn't even were loose ends all the way back to the first book, that it's very satisfying anyway. And I did not see the final plot points coming, which I always appreciate. If Sanderson ever learns how to write people as well as he creates world systems he'll have my undying fandom, but he's not quite there yet.
I'm giving this book 5 stars over the customary 4 star rating I would have simply because the "wrap-up" of the story is so complete! I don't know if I can explain this better, but Sanderson manages to tie up every single loose thread through all 3 books in this final book.
There are some minor slip-ups eg: When Vin is metal-less and fights Marsh (Yomen's chambers), she pulls a vial from him and recharges herself. Then she proceeds to burn duralumin, something that Marsh would definitely not have, because Inquisitors cannot burn it , but on the whole, I'm really impressed with Sanderson's ability to explain everything in his world, making it seem plausible and enhancing the reading experience tremendously.
A deeply satisfying end to a pretty good trilogy. The ending is a bit too pat, but the journey was exciting. Also, I am happy that my favorite character ended up being the most important!
やっと「即位の泉」や「時代の勇士」に関わる質問が明白になるかと思いきや、また新しい何かが現れます。自分はその展開を察知しませんでした。それにミストスピリットの生体もまだ未明です。知りたくてなりません!
主人公の周りにいる人物が続々と殺害されますが、全滅しなくて「生き残り」は次巻でどうするか楽しみにしています。
I really enjoyed this book and recommend it in English or Japanese. The series is 素晴らしい!
This was a very satisfying conclusion to the Mistborn trilogy. All the details of the previous book snapped into place, actions and characters made more sense. I think it's a great third book that makes you go back and think about the previous two in a new light and with a newly expanded perspective. I really liked how Sanderson used the excerpts at the beginning of the chapters throughout the series, but in Hero of Ages they managed to explain a lot of the cosmic goings-on without seeming out of place. It was a good trick of exposition to fill that stuff in without hammering the reader over the head with world-building knowledge. I also really enjoyed how willing Sanderson was to take dramatic turns with his characters, giving Spook, Elend, Vin, Sazed, TenSoon, and even Marsh satisfying arcs that fit with their characters but didn't edge too far into …
This was a very satisfying conclusion to the Mistborn trilogy. All the details of the previous book snapped into place, actions and characters made more sense. I think it's a great third book that makes you go back and think about the previous two in a new light and with a newly expanded perspective. I really liked how Sanderson used the excerpts at the beginning of the chapters throughout the series, but in Hero of Ages they managed to explain a lot of the cosmic goings-on without seeming out of place. It was a good trick of exposition to fill that stuff in without hammering the reader over the head with world-building knowledge. I also really enjoyed how willing Sanderson was to take dramatic turns with his characters, giving Spook, Elend, Vin, Sazed, TenSoon, and even Marsh satisfying arcs that fit with their characters but didn't edge too far into predictability. Even having read the synopses before hand, I was almost surprised going through, but it didn't feel particularly forced (well maybe Sazed a little, but he's a good dude I'll cut him some slack).
I probably would have given the book five stars just for fulfilling my desires to deliver me more Mistborn content, but I think the pacing was a bit off. The "Sanderson avalanche" is definitely a thing, but it was more noticeable in Hero of Ages. For a book that's over 700 pages, all the action of the finale shouldn't be packed into 50 odd pages at the end. It wasn't bad by any means, but I think a more experienced writer (or a post-WoT Sanderson) would trim the middle segments a bit and draw out the ending another 50 pages. It's really a cosmic-scale conflict at the end and it deserves a bigger chunk of the book.
All in all, I really loved this series. I have Alloy of Law waiting on my table, and plan to dive headlong into Sanderson again once I've cleared my reading list a little more. I'm a convert.
.
Third book of the Mistborn trilogy. It takes place a year or so after the events of the second book and... well, the world needs to be saved, essentially, if it's even possible. Great ending to a great series. All ends are tied, the whole series is consistent and fascinating (I really, really love the magic system) and the crescendo from the start to the end of the trilogy is directed with a master's hand. I had a very hard time letting go of this book ("another chapter tonight? that's not reasonable... last one, promise! okay, THIS ONE is the last one, promise!"). The ending is epic, grandiose and moving (it's quite rare that a book brings tears to my eyes). There's a Mistborn #4 that takes place 300 years later, it just landed on my "to-read" list.
2022 Re-read: If this book could get more than five stars it would deserve it.
"That's a pleasant sentiment, I think," Sazed said. Completely false, of course.
Hero of Ages is a magnificent read and enough time had passed that most of the story felt new and unfamiliar. The Sanderlanche is epic because it has to conclude the book, and the Mistborn Era 1 series; the first (and currently only) time a Sanderson Cosmere series has come to an end.
I loved the revelations of why historical events were they way they were, how there were enough clues to point the reader in one direction but then were taken in a different and even more appropriate conclusion.
Love this book and this series, I'm happy to re-read it and will probably be just as happy when I read this book again a few years down the road.
2018 Re-read …
2022 Re-read: If this book could get more than five stars it would deserve it.
"That's a pleasant sentiment, I think," Sazed said. Completely false, of course.
Hero of Ages is a magnificent read and enough time had passed that most of the story felt new and unfamiliar. The Sanderlanche is epic because it has to conclude the book, and the Mistborn Era 1 series; the first (and currently only) time a Sanderson Cosmere series has come to an end.
I loved the revelations of why historical events were they way they were, how there were enough clues to point the reader in one direction but then were taken in a different and even more appropriate conclusion.
Love this book and this series, I'm happy to re-read it and will probably be just as happy when I read this book again a few years down the road.
2018 Re-read: Charging ahead with re-reading the first Era Mistborn series.
...the winning side wasn't always the right side.
This series was better on the re-read. The struggles with faith, religion and belief was a thread under this final story and is a significant element. Having more knowledge of the Cosmere made me appreciate how much was introduced in this series. There were references to the Realms, some hints at Shards, but seeing the clues for something bigger was a nice pay off.
An excellent story, great character arcs (and for some you'd never think could be redeemed) and still a solid five star rating.
And is an ending always bad? it asked. Must not all things, even worlds, someday end?
In a word, this book, and series, was spectacular. The Hero of Ages beautifully connects the dots from the first two books while expanding on the mythology and helping you learn more about legends that were discussed in The Final Empire. The Hero of Ages did a fantastic job focusing on current events, elaborating on Hemalurgy, connecting the dots and being an entertaining read. My only regret is that the second Mistborn trilogy is not completed yet, however Mistborn #1-3 was a great series and I would recommend it for all fans of the fantasy genre.