Consider Phlebas

ePub, 480 pages

English language

Published May 11, 2008 by Little, Brown Book Group Limited.

ISBN:
978-0-7481-0999-9
Copied ISBN!

View on OpenLibrary

(283 reviews)

Consider Phlebas, first published in 1987, is a space opera novel by Scottish writer Iain M. Banks. It is the first in a series of novels about an interstellar post-scarcity society called the Culture. The novel revolves around the Idiran–Culture War, and Banks plays on that theme by presenting various microcosms of that conflict. Its protagonist Bora Horza Gobuchul is an enemy of the Culture. Consider Phlebas is Banks's first published science fiction novel and takes its title from a line in T. S. Eliot's poem The Waste Land. A subsequent Culture novel, Look to Windward (2000), whose title comes from the previous line of the same poem, can be considered a loose follow-up.

7 editions

reviewed Consider Phlebas by Iain M. Banks (Culture, #1)

Clearly I don't like Culture books

This is my third or fourth Culture book, and probably the one I liked least. Basically (theme on all my dislikes) I didn't like the characters, even the protagonist. And his motivation of "this side of the war, I guess" just didn't really feel like it held up.

I think on a re-read I'd be less irritated by how the protagonist (admittedly, realistically) just lurches from situation to situation without any real overarching plan, but as with every other Banks book, I struggle to summarise the plot simply. A lot of things happen but their end relation to the plot on the cover is low.

Review of 'Consider Phlebas' on 'Storygraph'

This is the second Banks I’ve read and I thought they were both terrific. Unlike some epic, galaxy-spanning space operas, this was pacey, smoothly written with great characters and loads of action and adventure.

Review of 'Consider Phlebas' on 'Goodreads'

Space opera #1 in a long series. The plot was like a superhero movie; why are they going there one wonders. Some characters, like those in a bad Western, were clearly introduced so that there was someone to die in the next big fight. I felt sorry for the poor bastards as soon as they were described. The underlying premise, the importance of The Mind, never seemed clear to me. I would have to classify it as an unusually transparent McGuffin. The protagonist's feelings about The Culture were unclear to me. I assume that the nature of the Culture would become more clear if I read more of these novels. (See famous quote attributed to Giacomo Rossini re: Wagner's Ring) Also, there were some attempts at stream-of-consciousness that were unsuccessful.

Elements of a Great SciFi but Not Executed

No real world building even though the world we get a glimpse of is fascinating. We are left wanting and not in a good way. A lot of it was, well, meaningless. We want this book to be more. We actually need it to be more. That it doesn't even com close is what is so depressing. That said, we are eager to read the next recommended book in the series to hopefully see if he does give us more, in a good way.

A ton of imaginative concepts but it doesn't quite work

Content warning Mild spoilers

The Culture begins

I remember seeing this in a book shop with a shiny silver highlight on the cover, and recognisng the name of the author of "The Wasp Factory", which I had read and really enjoyed. But what was he doing in the SF section, and what was the "M" all about? I guessed correctly that here was an author living a double life in so-called literature AND my home base of genre fiction, especially SF. And I found his SF was far superior to his realistic fiction or whatever you call that rubbish :-).

On early readings I didn't quite absorb the brilliant creation of Banks' future utopia the Culture, partly because this first novel highlights a character who has turned against this pan-galactic anarchist society, and worked for a religious extremist society sworn to destroy it. It's like Banks wanted to stress-test his perfect society by portraying one of its …

Review of 'Consider Phlebas' on 'Storygraph'

Mostly escapist science fiction because I have an annoying cold and am low on energy.
It is about the clash of a post-capitalist culture and an imperialist one though, however unlikely, the "good folks" are human(oid) and the war-making imperialists are not.

It's the first of Banks' Culture novels, which I've read several times; I'm starting over though it will take me a while as I'll save them for when my attention span is low.

Consider Phlebas

Cela faisait un moment que je voulais lire le cycle de la Culture de Iain M. Banks et je me suis enfin décidé à m'y mettre. Je ne sais pas si je dois me réjouir d'avoir autant attendu ou regretter de ne pas l'avoir fait plus tôt, tout est-il que le premier roman du cycle m'a beaucoup plu.

Le récit est rythmé et finalement assez classique. On s'attache énormément aux personnages et on suit avec plaisir leurs aventures et mésaventures. Surtout, l'univers est original, on pressent une grande richesse à explorer dans la suite du cycle. C'est de la science-fiction inventive et intelligente, tout ce que j'aime.

Review of 'Consider Phlebas' on 'Goodreads'

Bad. The setting of the Culture is interesting but the author's sense of storytelling and pacing is horrible. For a series about the Culture, I was surprised that the novel is from the viewpoint of someone who is fighting against them. I learned very little about the thing I wanted to read about.

The story is bogged down by internal monologuing, info dumps, and scene changes to the literal other side of the galaxy. There are a number of chapters that are entirely superfluous -- the worst of which is a digression onto an island of religious fanatics (no spoilers but the chapter name actually tells you what will happen). The writing is so long-winded that you'll start skimming, and then immediately miss a throwaway line that is critical to the next few pages of action. Even during the climax of the novel, the author decides to break up the …

Arrogance

This is a book about arrogance. The arrogance of going up against a culture (indeed, THE Culture) that can do anything, of going up against the certainty of faith, of going it alone, of reliance on technology or the rejection of it. I spent a while thinking about what this book is "about" after its unusual conclusion. I think it's ultimately about how very important it is to work together, to be together. A culture that destroys individualism so thoroughly that each person is ultimately disconnected from every other is as bad as a religious community that rejects common ground with other communities, which is itself as bad as a man who is driven only to accomplish his own ends. Every bad thing that happens to an individual is either the result of working alone--even with the best intentions--or of an uncaring, random universe inflicting itself on people left unprotected. …

It's a space opera. What do you want?

I definitely enjoyed this more than (Surface Detail)[https://book.dansmonorage.blue/book/18939]. If nothing else, it is notably shorter, which suggests an instance of "established authors need editing too".

Banks does love to shock, and loves to write "cinematically", which occasionally a bit tiresome.

While I think describing the Culture series as "Literary Science Fiction" is a bit of stretch, there are some interesting big picture ideas, and some of the characters have some depth, or at least some interior life. The choice of having a "bad guy" protagonist already elevates it beyond a lot of more pulpy SF.

Review of 'Consider Phlebas' on 'Goodreads'

Much ado about nothing.

I really liked how this started off. A protagonist thrown from one deadly encounter to another, sort of like Indiana Jones. The final act takes a surprising turn into what amounts to a slow dungeon crawl, then the epilogue ties things up in a way that I consider deeply unsatisfying.

Review of 'Consider Phlebas' on 'Goodreads'

This book is a good example of why Goodreads needs a status for books called “Abandoned” or “Didn’t finish”. Ugh, made it 20% of the way through it and decided that it was pointless gore and misery. Too many good books out there to waste time with books like this.

avatar for loppear

rated it

avatar for lucasrizoli

rated it

avatar for lamnatos

rated it

avatar for jimfingal

rated it

avatar for finity

rated it

avatar for wilw

rated it

avatar for gappleto97

rated it

avatar for Lasu

rated it

avatar for ckochx

rated it

avatar for james

rated it

avatar for fallaciousreasoning

rated it

avatar for secretGeek

rated it

avatar for Lasu

rated it

avatar for evanstucker

rated it

avatar for agd

rated it

avatar for agd

rated it

avatar for cubeofwood

rated it

avatar for samullen

rated it

avatar for asmundg

rated it

avatar for moopet

rated it

avatar for squaregoldfish

rated it

avatar for AnthonyPerrett

rated it

avatar for tmladek

rated it

avatar for maese_richar

rated it

avatar for qnm

rated it

avatar for masyukun

rated it

avatar for Yogthos

rated it

avatar for mikec

rated it

avatar for akkartik

rated it

avatar for ianbetteridge

rated it

avatar for stim

rated it

avatar for Tamino

rated it

avatar for oisin

rated it

avatar for ngs

rated it

avatar for jumpinggrendel

rated it

avatar for wakatara

rated it

avatar for tmarsh1024

rated it

avatar for IndustrialRobot

rated it

avatar for dan_oglesby

rated it

avatar for jelmervdl

rated it

avatar for Dunedinmouse

rated it

avatar for paparomeo

rated it

avatar for Chigaze

rated it

avatar for wajib

rated it

avatar for whitmad

rated it

avatar for knizer

rated it

avatar for John47

rated it

avatar for rgibert

rated it

avatar for Old_Tim

rated it

avatar for sajattack

rated it

avatar for RPhlegm

rated it

avatar for hel

rated it

avatar for lbthomas

rated it

avatar for timhutton

rated it

avatar for joeyh

rated it

avatar for awboonstra

rated it

avatar for Korenwolf

rated it

avatar for fabriek

rated it

avatar for vertis

rated it

avatar for erinmalone

rated it

avatar for Blerkotron

rated it

avatar for CaptainCornflake

rated it

avatar for wafonso

rated it

avatar for osiris

rated it

avatar for Antolius

rated it

avatar for rschulman

rated it

avatar for stinkingpig

rated it

avatar for Ba5ilisk

rated it

avatar for yallah110

rated it

avatar for younger

rated it

avatar for abekonge

rated it

avatar for suddzzjr

rated it

avatar for cara-cara

rated it

avatar for Doomedrider

rated it

avatar for Ivia

rated it

avatar for Hirvox

rated it

avatar for sebastost

rated it

avatar for johnke

rated it

avatar for ranok

rated it

avatar for niclindh

rated it

avatar for Painkiller

rated it

avatar for proycon

rated it

avatar for ieuan

rated it

avatar for markodonohue

rated it

avatar for spiralmind

rated it

avatar for cerieshunter

rated it

avatar for Allenshull

rated it

avatar for count

rated it

avatar for AndySoc1al

rated it

avatar for bombpersons

rated it

avatar for Maerman

rated it

avatar for timchi

rated it

avatar for hammondj

rated it

avatar for hexarchate

rated it

avatar for turmacar

rated it

avatar for state_electrician

rated it

avatar for nightgolfer

rated it

avatar for AwkwardTurtle

rated it

avatar for OrangutansLibrary

rated it

avatar for AudientVoid

rated it

avatar for neosloth

rated it

avatar for Shack70

rated it

avatar for dx

rated it

avatar for m4cb3th

rated it

avatar for sidmitra

rated it

avatar for gtco

rated it

avatar for rahulgopinath

rated it

avatar for Turtle4233

rated it

avatar for OffbeatPulse

rated it

avatar for jimfl

rated it

avatar for tshannon

rated it

avatar for rechtsstaat

rated it

avatar for mbraagaard

rated it

avatar for wanderbaer

rated it

avatar for YouNaughtyMonsters

rated it

avatar for spacewrangler

rated it

avatar for brunosan

rated it

avatar for snm

rated it

avatar for trevor

rated it

avatar for acidman

rated it

avatar for lacop

rated it

avatar for dev_tea

rated it

avatar for themoken

rated it

avatar for Jorn

rated it

avatar for kevbot9000

rated it

avatar for GeorgeAlfredBlack

rated it

avatar for mjdiliscia

rated it

avatar for jamesbrooks

rated it

avatar for Coornail

rated it

avatar for engwalker

rated it

avatar for diversario

rated it

avatar for cwzp

rated it

avatar for mivade

rated it

avatar for hamish

rated it

avatar for Gretrascis

rated it

avatar for pneuma

rated it

avatar for rankle

rated it

avatar for princeofspace

rated it

avatar for jmc142

rated it

avatar for Pablonaj

rated it

avatar for ahalbert

rated it

avatar for nwale

rated it

avatar for tsukikage

rated it

avatar for peter_hall

rated it

avatar for grislyeye

rated it

avatar for estranho

rated it

avatar for chaos_angel

rated it

avatar for Psvensson

rated it

avatar for jhaase

rated it

avatar for Shtakser

rated it

avatar for WorzelFG

rated it

avatar for BillieCodes

rated it

avatar for tronicdude

rated it

avatar for StereoSoda

rated it

avatar for mandugar

rated it

avatar for pdrbstmnt

rated it

avatar for rleyton

rated it

avatar for jolson

rated it

avatar for naught101

rated it

avatar for bentreegecko

rated it

avatar for termie

rated it

avatar for recri

rated it

avatar for ward

rated it

avatar for veganmashuu

rated it

avatar for rosssi

rated it

avatar for inti

rated it

avatar for robphippen

rated it

avatar for flancian

rated it

avatar for kranzi

rated it

avatar for barryfujii

rated it

avatar for drizzy

rated it

avatar for marksutherland

rated it

avatar for Njdevils95

rated it

avatar for ospalh

rated it

avatar for justanotherrandomuser

rated it

avatar for MatthiasvW

rated it

avatar for pd-bomber

rated it

avatar for moritzheiber

rated it

avatar for Lunartech

rated it

avatar for CMGX9

rated it

avatar for MIsForAwesome

rated it

avatar for tjrourke

rated it

avatar for kosure

rated it

avatar for armamix@books.infosec.exchange

rated it

avatar for acdha

rated it

avatar for Tinche

rated it

avatar for Anders_S

rated it

avatar for rpearce

rated it

avatar for Owl_of_Minerva

rated it

avatar for ToddSchroth

rated it

avatar for stombeur

rated it

avatar for matthewmincher

rated it

avatar for jjackunrau

rated it

avatar for hastur

rated it

avatar for ulfurinn

rated it

avatar for pnyx

rated it

avatar for fear025

rated it

avatar for emuspawn

rated it

avatar for smyth

rated it

avatar for yo.ian.g

rated it

avatar for Mansoul

rated it

avatar for balise

rated it

avatar for kotnik

rated it

avatar for milsyobtaf

rated it

avatar for Sugarwhatbro

rated it

avatar for mad_frisbeterian

rated it

avatar for richardmorton

rated it

avatar for zelse

rated it

avatar for scottkillen

rated it

avatar for bayl.as

rated it

avatar for ppetermann

rated it

avatar for dshafik

rated it

avatar for georgewhatup

rated it

avatar for Vintervind

rated it

avatar for deoxys314

rated it

avatar for stefanschulz

rated it

avatar for hyrrokkin

rated it

avatar for willhopkins

rated it

avatar for leighelse

rated it

avatar for datwizzerd

rated it

avatar for hw@bookrastinating.com

rated it

avatar for skribe

rated it

avatar for crb

rated it

avatar for FranCadaval

rated it

avatar for Contortion

rated it

avatar for Scordatura

rated it

avatar for tamcymru

rated it

avatar for asiem

rated it

avatar for cygnoir

rated it

avatar for valkyrie

rated it

avatar for valkyrie

rated it

avatar for borup

rated it

avatar for ssatl

rated it

avatar for uhhuhthem@wyrmsign.org

rated it

avatar for michelin

rated it

avatar for btuftin

rated it

avatar for froderik

rated it

avatar for eagleeyedtiger

rated it

avatar for Xifax

rated it

avatar for vile_reads

rated it

avatar for Llesca

rated it

avatar for klugerama

rated it

avatar for Trentie

rated it

avatar for betolima

rated it

avatar for lnklnx

rated it

avatar for spodonkidonk

rated it

Subjects

  • Fiction, science fiction, space opera
  • Fiction, science fiction, action & adventure

Lists