I wish Tom Sawyer didn't show up
3 stars
It was a decent read, but Tom Sawyer ruined my enjoyment of the story.
Paperback
English language
Published July 8, 2003 by Penguin Books.
'Other places do seem so cramped up and smothery, but a raft don't. You feel mighty free and easy and comfortable on a raft" Mark Twain's tale of a boy's picaresque journey down the Mississippi on a raft conveyed the voice and experience of the American frontier as no other work has done before. When Huck escapes from his drunken father and the 'sivilizing' Widow Douglas with the runaway slave Jim, he embarks on a series of adventures that draw him to feuding families and the trickery of the unscrupulous 'Duke' and 'Daupin'. Beneath the exploits, however, are more serious undercurrents--of slavery, adult control and, above all, of Huck's struggle between his instinctive goodness and the corrupt values of society, which threaten his deep and enduring frienship with Jim.
This edition uses the text from the first edition of 1884 and includes a new chronology and suggestions for further reading. …
'Other places do seem so cramped up and smothery, but a raft don't. You feel mighty free and easy and comfortable on a raft" Mark Twain's tale of a boy's picaresque journey down the Mississippi on a raft conveyed the voice and experience of the American frontier as no other work has done before. When Huck escapes from his drunken father and the 'sivilizing' Widow Douglas with the runaway slave Jim, he embarks on a series of adventures that draw him to feuding families and the trickery of the unscrupulous 'Duke' and 'Daupin'. Beneath the exploits, however, are more serious undercurrents--of slavery, adult control and, above all, of Huck's struggle between his instinctive goodness and the corrupt values of society, which threaten his deep and enduring frienship with Jim.
This edition uses the text from the first edition of 1884 and includes a new chronology and suggestions for further reading. (back cover)
It was a decent read, but Tom Sawyer ruined my enjoyment of the story.
In the words of one of my students, "Sometimes I forget that Huck isn't real."
Very good book.
Ha sido una historia tierna con una relación sencilla.
Too much tell and not enough show. Both MC's spent too many pages in their heads instead of interacting. Skimmed dozens of pages of gratuitous sex scenes. Not much plot in this one.
It is bizarre reading this in 2020 in the context of the protests and Black Lives Matter, but it is illuminating, at least insofar as it regards from where this all has sprung. I don't know that I can recommend the read while all this is so raw.
Audible. Elijah Wood was outstanding as the narrator.
A really good read, much better than Tom Sawyer. It was funnier and more heartfelt than Tom, with a character who thought he wasn't any good but really was a great kid, despite his challenges. Catching up late on these two classics, but this one had way more memorable characters and told a more interesting story.
It's biggest drawback was that it was a "quest" story. I am not a big fan of quest stories. These are usually the domain of fantasy or science fiction, so the author can throw all kinds of disconnected but "interesting" vignettes at you. They never seem to hang together all that well for me, and don't tell a cohesive story. It is kind of like a dream sequence, where there are no repercussions or any need for connections as the story goes along.
So I often find it hard to pay attention. This …
A really good read, much better than Tom Sawyer. It was funnier and more heartfelt than Tom, with a character who thought he wasn't any good but really was a great kid, despite his challenges. Catching up late on these two classics, but this one had way more memorable characters and told a more interesting story.
It's biggest drawback was that it was a "quest" story. I am not a big fan of quest stories. These are usually the domain of fantasy or science fiction, so the author can throw all kinds of disconnected but "interesting" vignettes at you. They never seem to hang together all that well for me, and don't tell a cohesive story. It is kind of like a dream sequence, where there are no repercussions or any need for connections as the story goes along.
So I often find it hard to pay attention. This one managed to avoid that for a while, as Huck Finn and Jim, thrown together by accident, float down the mighty Mississippi. Perhaps because Twain didn't feel like he was in a rush to tell stories, the story felt as languid and deep as the river itself.
There were a couple interesting incidents. I particularly liked the one where Huck Finn, for reasons that escape me, dressed up as a girl and ended up in a long conversation with a woman in her home. He was trying his best to keep up the facade, but you could tell she saw right through him. I really liked the bit where she threw something heavy at him and he caught it in his dress. Later, she explained that she knew he was a boy because he caught it by bringing his knees together, where a girl would have spread her legs to catch it in the dress itself. Small insights like these are what really kept Huck Finn interesting for me.
But eventually the traveling down the river just took too long. While the King and the Duke were interesting for a bit, for a pair of frauds, that went on for a little too long. And how he ended up running back into Tom Sawyer required a real suspension of disbelief. And the whole time Tom Sawyer was around, while there were some pretty funny incidents, especially as they made Jim act out Tom's ideas of a book perfect escape, also went along too long and stretched credulity to the far limits.
Much like Tom Sawyer, the casual vicious racism of the period depicted is both jarring and depressing. Written in 1884, and set in the 1840s, it really is nightmarish just how sub-human the whites of the time felt the African Americans were. This book emphasizes in a few places just how the white folks, even the poorest of them, held the slaves and ex-slaves as barely above, or probably equal to, dogs in the social scale. The way the N word is tossed around is just so hard to take. I think Mark Twain realized it too, because he probably humanized Jim more than most authors would have at the time, but it still burns a hole in your soul just reading about it.
So in the end, probably more of a 4.5 book. But I laughed enough and enjoyed the growth of Huck Finn enough, that it is easy to round it up to a 5 star book. I am not sure but you probably ought to make sure you read Tom Sawyer first. This is, in my opinion, a far superior book, but I think you'll understand the characters and setting more if you read Tom first. But, in any case, highly recommended. And the audiobook, read by Grover Gardner, is really well done. The vernacular is pretty heavy in this book and he does a fantastic job with all of them.
Man, it's been a while and I forgot how annoying Tom Sawyer can be.
A bloody good adventure, Huck is the man, he hunts, can read the river well, when stuck in a dire situation he is calm as a cucumber and will swim down to the river bed to avoid a steam boat wheel and his final gift is the ability to weave a story at a moments notice.
Then you got Jim, a runaway slave, made out to be a bit slow like all slaves were considered turns out to be a bright spark with as much wit about him as Huck has.
The third character appears in the last third of the book, the mighty Tom Sawyer himself. The guy is a genius of madness. You gotta feel sorry for Jim for having to put up with Tom's schemes, but at least he is game to go along with them.
There seems to be a lot of complaint about the racism …
A bloody good adventure, Huck is the man, he hunts, can read the river well, when stuck in a dire situation he is calm as a cucumber and will swim down to the river bed to avoid a steam boat wheel and his final gift is the ability to weave a story at a moments notice.
Then you got Jim, a runaway slave, made out to be a bit slow like all slaves were considered turns out to be a bright spark with as much wit about him as Huck has.
The third character appears in the last third of the book, the mighty Tom Sawyer himself. The guy is a genius of madness. You gotta feel sorry for Jim for having to put up with Tom's schemes, but at least he is game to go along with them.
There seems to be a lot of complaint about the racism in this book, but I think it is necessary, that was how things were in those days. Reading what is going on in huck's head as he battles what has been ingrained in his brain, he starts to realise that Jim is a person and deserves freedom made for some great reading.
I had a massive grin on my face for the last 50 pages or so, brilliant fun and very moving at times, I really enjoyed this adventure.
The audio quality was not so great on this one.
More like 3.5
"The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn," Mark Twain's most famous novel, is an absolute masterpiece. First published 1884, the story details the exciting adventures of Huck Finn, a boy who refuses to succumb to apathy. Along the way, he encounters Jim, a runaway slave, and their explorations shake the very foundation of their shared existence. Twain explores a multitude of pivotal matters, such as bigotry, racism, brotherhood, war, religion, and freedom. While Twain's mantra has the ability to inspire lighthearted hilarity, it is the commentary on this central issues that drives the narrative forward. "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" is a heavy-hearted work of staggering genius that absolutely everyone ought to read.
It was great until Tom Sawyer showed up
There's nothing I can say about this book that hasn't been said better. This is just a note about the BBC Audio CD: it's terrific.